Audio Project Amplifier Speaker Loudspeaker Kit
diyAudio.com diyAudio Forums Archive > Top > Loudspeakers > ESLs, planars, alternative technologies
 
Open baffle subs and Maggies - Click HERE for Original Thread
Luke G
I've decided that I'm going to get another pair of Maggies. I sold my last pair of modified MG-I's in search of greener grass. Should have kept them...

Anyways, I've listened to the Emerald Physics CS2's and I was very impressed with the Eminence 15A's that they use. I'm thinking of doing something similar, four 15A's and an SMS-1 to control them.

Any thoughts on that setup before I jump headfirst into it? I haven't seen much talk of OB subs being used with Magnepans before and was curious if there might be a reason behind it.

Thanks ahead of time.
Ed Holland
Luke, you may know about this already, but check out the Maggie Users' Group (MUG) and related links: http://www.integracoustics.com/MUG/MUG/

I have read that integrating with a sub requires a little extra patience, though have not attempted this myself - I think there is info, or links to it via the MUG. I'm perfectly happy with a healthy pair of SMGa speakers.

Cheers,

Ed
Luke G
Thanks! I have been to the site before, but the name escaped me.
studiotech
MB Quart 12s powered by a Nady XA1100 crossed over @ 70Hz. Low pass shelved EQ @ 40 Hz of about 10dB per octave.

Greg
Luke G
Greg, I'm not seeing an image.
studiotech
Let's try this again.
studiotech
and one in the system.
Luke G
Thanks Greg! Could you please elaborate a bit on the driver selection and enclosure design?
studiotech
Just a normal "H" baffle. Dimensions are 34" W * 18" H * 16" D.

The woofers seemed like a good gamble at the time. I was considering the Dayton Reference 12" which were the newest thing going back then, but I spotted these on some clearance sale from Crutchfield that was buy one for $100 and get one free! To make the deal even sweeter, they were offereing free shipping on orders over $299, so I got that too! I ended up with 6, thinking of an IB set-up, but that didn't work out so I whipped up the "H" baffles and haven't looked back since.

They turned out to be really great for an open baffle system. Very quite at high excursions, no air chuffing or misc rubbing/flapping sounds and don't require much EQ thanks to the Qts of .5.

See here for the specs and a larger image.

http://www.crutchfield.com/App/Prod...tures_and_specs
Kensai
Check this thread and MJK's paper that it refers to:

MJK's OB thread

Even if you're not using MMG-Ws (the only single driver maggie), the theory there should apply, and given that Maggies are pretty insensitive, you shouldn't have any trouble mating them with a proper OB woofer. In fact, the whole thing is based around the assumption of using Eminence 15As.

Kensai
LineSource
Dipoles cannot pressurize a room, and so cannot reach frequencies below the fundamental room mode. For deep bass in modest volume rooms, consider a bipolar woofer, which has mass cancelation and 4-PI radiation.

Page generated in 0.029956102371216 seconds with 17 queries,
spending 0.00766730 doing MySQL queries and 0.02228880 doing PHP things.

Powered by: Search Engine Indexer and vBulletin
Copyright ©1999-2008 diyAudio.com