Simplistic MosFET HV Shunt Regs

My personal summary of this thread:
1. According to the late Allen Wright, the power supply quality has 50% responsibility for the sound quality of an amplifier.
2. Shunt Regulators are the best possible regulators - wherever it's possible to use them (it's usually impossible to use them with reactive load, like output transformer or inter-stage transformer{s}). They are the best possible regulators both from the technical-engineering view and from listening reports.
3. Salas Shunt Regulators are easy to build, even with point-to-point wiring, and according to the testimonies of many users - give excellent results.
My bottom line:
The Salas HV Shunt Regulator is the most highly recommended solution to any tube pre-amp, including phono stages - and to the voltage stage(s) of any tube power amp.
 
My personal summary of this thread:
2. Shunt Regulators are the best possible regulators - wherever it's possible to use them (it's usually impossible to use them with reactive load, like output transformer or inter-stage transformer{s}). They are the best possible regulators both from the technical-engineering view and from listening reports.
.


I know at least two or three of us are using it with output transformer loads without issue. This is a SSHV single feed 5k:32 OPT WE417, 2H-60db, the bump at 60hz(under -100db) is from the power transformer emi into the opt:

5842spud-finalfft.jpg
 
Truly unique build. The BC transistors first reg in direct to chassis dead bug wiring! Are you sure you want to dismantle that for a later update?:)

Hi Salas

I tried to review this thread up to page 192 and cannot find the circuit that matched the above like you said is the latest version. Would you tell me D5 and D7 should be 1N4003 or 12V zener?

Because some latest circuit showed that D5 to D8 is all 12V zener including the redrawn circuit by Mr. Quang Hao.

I just P-to-P again last night but it didn't work. ha ha ha .......................:p

Thanks

Tim
 
Hi Salas

Problem solved. A very careless mistake:the regulator did not grounded !!!!

A preliminary test is the audible hum, it is very very quite !!!!! The first version I still got an audible buzz......y............., but this time it is nothing can be audible !!

Thanks for your masterpiece !!!!!

Now is mid night in Hong Kong, I have to play it tomorrow.:D

Tim
 
Nice. Did you leave the diode-zener protection connected to gates as in the drawn circuit when it got grounded and worked?

The diode - zener protection was disconnected and found no problem, the regulator turned on up to this time seems no problem too and I proposed not to connect this protection.

P-to-P of transistors circuit is very interesting than tube....:D
 
OK , protection will be added up later, when I get lazy enough:D

I found that the 120K connected to 2SK170 is very hot! My finger cannot stand for few seconds on it, maybe one second something.

The regulator current set at 42ma something, R1 is 47 ohms, raw DC input is 380V after load. R3 set to 79K by series connection of 10K + 22K + 47K.

Also use red LED for ref voltage of 2SK170, for nice look purpose and indeed it looks nice !!!

Except the Solen cap., all others are very cheap components.

This morning I play the amp. and feeling better than before. Don't know use cosmetic words to describe the change, but to me , it is very "stereo" and "attractive".
 

Attachments

  • New Ver 1.jpg
    New Ver 1.jpg
    490.5 KB · Views: 568
  • New ver 3.JPG
    New ver 3.JPG
    410.1 KB · Views: 534
  • New Ver 4.JPG
    New Ver 4.JPG
    331 KB · Views: 519
The brown color cheap metal film cap is for the by pass purpose of the lift up voltage for cathode follower filament.

Star ground used for the regulator , totally six ground points for the whole circuit if zener protection not included. That's the point that was missing to connect a wire to the raw DC ground point !!
 
diyAudio Chief Moderator
Joined 2002
Paid Member
OK , protection will be added up later, when I get lazy enough:D

I found that the 120K connected to 2SK170 is very hot! My finger cannot stand for few seconds on it, maybe one second something.

The regulator current set at 42ma something, R1 is 47 ohms, raw DC input is 380V after load. R3 set to 79K by series connection of 10K + 22K + 47K.

Also use red LED for ref voltage of 2SK170, for nice look purpose and indeed it looks nice !!!

Except the Solen cap., all others are very cheap components.

This morning I play the amp. and feeling better than before. Don't know use cosmetic words to describe the change, but to me , it is very "stereo" and "attractive".

Nice spider's web, traditional. Big gate resistors and long legs here, its not like in tight PCB with tiny gate stoppers, better avoid adding more components around the gate paths since it works reliably for you now, I am afraid it might get extra ghost inductance. There is ~1W on that 120K if you use it for 350Vout for example. Since you find that one does not take it well, use two 68k in series like that one, or one 120k double fat. Its good you could find it better by changing version, so it was not work for no reason. Regards.
 
Current Update?

Hey Salas,

Just wondering where this reg is currently at? I have Nov 09 dated schematics I am looking to use for +/-200v, is there an updated version i can use? P2P is ok, or I can get vero board?

Want to use these in a dac for the B+ on the output tubes, would appreciate a looksee if there is an update about? Trying to keep up to speed on this forum is a little hard sometimes, not sure how you do it!

Thanks,

Drew.
 

iko

Ex-Moderator
Joined 2008
Technically if you want the achieve the lowest output impedance that the design might allow you should use force/sense connections. However, we started talking about the Kelvin connection only when I introduced the bjt buffer before the shunt mostfet on the low voltage circuit, where the design promised low output impedance well beyond 20kHz. In that case, there was no way to achieve it without the Kelvin connection. If the current Salas HV schematic doesn't have the buffer, then you don't worry about low output impedance at 20kHz anyway. The HV shunt reg that I built recently has both the bjt buffer and the force/sense wires, and low output impedance in a wide frequency range.
 

iko

Ex-Moderator
Joined 2008
Hey Salas, I spent some time on my HV shunt reg recently and ran into an issue which might be an issue for you guys too.

226983d1307977267-simplistic-mosfet-hv-shunt-regs-regulated_salas_pos-neg.jpg


I'm talking about the 2SK170 (Q4) and MJE350 (Q2), because I'm using this pair exactly in my reg too. I've had a number of them go puff because of spikes at turn on/off, although you'd think that the E-B junction of the MJE350 would not allow a high voltage across the 2SK170. A 12V zener across the 2SK170 fixed the issue entirely for me and I've been using the regulator trouble free ever since. The rest of the reg is different than yours, different CCS, and bjt buffer on the shunt mosfet, to get low Zout beyond 15kHz.