diyAudio

diyAudio (http://www.diyaudio.com/forums/)
-   Parts (http://www.diyaudio.com/forums/parts/)
-   -   Black Gate 'super E' caps (http://www.diyaudio.com/forums/parts/7593-black-gate-super-e-caps.html)

Terry Demol 13th November 2002 09:19 PM

Black Gate 'super E' caps
 
Hi all,

Has anyone here tried 'super E' configuration
of Black Gate N series caps?
I have read all the literature but cannot
understand how inductances can fully cancel
of a pair without the two caps occupying the same
physical space ie; having VH mutual inductance.

Is this snake oil or what?

PS I have also posted this on AA.

Thanks,

Terry

halojoy 13th November 2002 09:43 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by Terry Demol
Has anyone here tried .... Black Gate .... caps?

Is this snake oil or what?

I would not spend my money on any WET electrolyte called Black Gate or anything in that category of salesmanship.

This is a view that might cause a slight confusion and debate.
And probably cause disliking of me as a person.
But a person is not made up of only one view in one matter.

See also a simular statement of me:
http://www.diyaudio.com/forums/showt...SCON#post81349

arnach 13th November 2002 10:20 PM

> And probably cause disliking of me as a person.

Certainly not.

You prefer OSCONs?

I prefer no electroyltics at all..

Ric Schultz 13th November 2002 10:22 PM

Terry,
The non-polar Blackgates have an outside foil. The outside foil is hooked up to the longer or shorter lead (probably the shorter). So when you hook two of them up in parallel and one of them with lead reversed they are suppose to cancel inductance. Not being an engineer, I cannot say how this works, but many people have tried it and claim the sound is improved. Try it and tell us what you hear.

Ric Schultz

jean-paul 13th November 2002 10:30 PM

Quote:

This is a view that might cause a slight confusion and debate.
Halojoy,

A view IMO is less worth than experience. Did you ever really try Black Gate ? I did and BG NX Hi Q ( what's in a name ) is the best electrolytic I ever used.
Apart from the marketing and the price( absurd, I know ) they are really comparable with film caps of the best quality. Something I certainly didn't believe before I tried them...

Fred Dieckmann 13th November 2002 11:47 PM

Black Gate
 
Ahhhh... more expert advice from the uninformed.....

The Black Gate caps sound better than many very good film caps that I have heard. Even the STD and PK series sound better than most polypropylene film types. For those who don't believe this please don't try them, so you leave more of them for those of us dare to make up our mind AFTER we listen. By the way, 47uF and above values for film caps are practically non existant and sound pretty bad. I have used the OSCONs also but they are not as good as the Black Gates.

http://www.referenceaudiomods.com/Me...Store_Code=RAM

neither cast ye your pearls before swine, lest they trample them under their feet,
Fred

Terry Demol 14th November 2002 11:15 AM

Quote:

Originally posted by Ric Schultz
Terry,
The non-polar Blackgates have an outside foil. The outside foil is hooked up to the longer or shorter lead (probably the shorter). So when you hook two of them up in parallel and one of them with lead reversed they are suppose to cancel inductance. Not being an engineer, I cannot say how this works, but many people have tried it and claim the sound is improved. Try it and tell us what you hear.

Ric Schultz

Gedday Rick,

Good to see your still around. Yes, I was aware of the
supposed mechanisms of inductance cancellation but
couldn't quite see it happening in the 'real world',
since I figured they would have to occupy the same
space for it to work correctly.

Anyway, I am going to be putting them in a super
tricked out SET that is already very nice so I will
get back and post my results. I am just being catious
after spending a bomb on AN magnetic Tantalum R's
that sounded only marginally better than some very old
large Beyshlags.

Keep on tweekin'

Regards,

Terry

raul_77 14th November 2002 11:24 AM

Hi all,

Before buy the very expensives Black Gate, please, wait to the last part of the article: "Sound of Capacitors?" that are actually published in Electronics World & Wireless World. You can save much money.

This final part (the six) expected are published in the first month of the next year. As are non published stuff, I cannot advance more.

Happy days,

Raśl Couto

Terry Demol 14th November 2002 11:25 AM

Quote:

Originally posted by jean-paul


Halojoy,

A view IMO is less worth than experience. Did you ever really try Black Gate ? I did and BG NX Hi Q ( what's in a name ) is the best electrolytic I ever used.
Apart from the marketing and the price( absurd, I know ) they are really comparable with film caps of the best quality. Something I certainly didn't believe before I tried them...

Thanks, yes I have tried the N series and also found
it very very good, however have yet to try the
super E config. Was hoping someone had done direct
comparison of 'super E' to same cap singular.

Terry

LaMa 14th November 2002 01:12 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by raul_77
Hi all,

Before buy the very expensives Black Gate, please, wait to the last part of the article: "Sound of Capacitors?" that are actually published in Electronics World & Wireless World. You can save much money.

This final part (the six) expected are published in the first month of the next year. As are non published stuff, I cannot advance more.

Happy days,

Raśl Couto

Very interesting, I hope they find a cost effective alternative :)


All times are GMT. The time now is 09:41 PM.


vBulletin Optimisation provided by vB Optimise (Pro) - vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2014 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.
Copyright ©1999-2014 diyAudio


Content Relevant URLs by vBSEO 3.3.2