Proper Grounding Scheme

Status
This old topic is closed. If you want to reopen this topic, contact a moderator using the "Report Post" button.
00940 said:
hum, I just realized that I had a tube amp running without earth. And no way to get one since my old outlet has no ground.

I just went back to my old manuals and .... Could I use an isolation transformer instead of earth ? More specifically, I've still at home one old heavy EI core stepdown transformer. It has jumpers for 1:1 and is rated for 600W (the amp is rated at 2w).


If you have a tube amp then it already has a transformer in it. All you need to do is install a 3 prong line cord and connect the green wire to the amp chassis. When you do this, check to see if you have one of the 3 position ON-OFf-ON power switches. Is so replace it with a normal ON/OFF switch. The 3 position switches were to let you swap the AC hot and neutral wires (the old 2 prong plugs aren't polarized to make sure you plug them in right). You won't need this 3 position switch once you have a proper line cord.

About your outlet not having a ground. Unless your house is very old, you most likely have a ground present in the outlet box. Older house wiring (pre-Romex) mostly used a two conductor cable inside of a flexible metal jacket. The metal jacket of the cable is your earth ground and it is terminated to the outlet box.

The simplest solution to your problem in this case is to use one of the 3 to 2 prong adapters and install it according to directions (connect the adapter ground wire or tab to the outlet cover screw which is grounded). I would prefer to replace the 2 prong outlets with 3 prong outlets and connect the outlet ground to the outlet box, but do this only if you know what you are doing.

If your house is really ancient, then it may not have grounded outlet boxes, in which case hire an electrician to install a proper circuit and outlet for your amp.

You can test for a grounded outlet box with an AC voltmeter. Measure between the hot and neutral and you should see around 120 VAC (US). Meter between the cover screw and the hot and you should also see around 120 V. Between the neutral and the cover screw should be less than 1 volt. If your box is not grounded then you will probably measure around 60 volts between the Hot and cover screw and 60 volts between the neutral and cover screw.

Phil
 
Ex-Moderator
Joined 2002
:cop:Jim,

Phil has explained the technical aspects of this issue very clearly. You may wire your systems how you see fit, but what you have suggested in your previous post is unsafe. This is against the rules of the forum (Rule #4). Please consider this an official warning and not pursue this debate any further.:cop:
 
Clarification

I would like to clarify the above, just to make sure I'm not gambling with my measurement set-up. It is a LM3875 in 2 boxes. The PS is in a 6x4-ish Radio Shack plastic box. It is connected via 3 wire Neutrik to a smaller box, also plastic, containing the rest of the amp. The only exposed metal are the screws (non-issue) and the RCA and binding posts. Even though there is a primary fuse, is there a real chance that the binding post or RCA could go live? Of course, since I'm asking the question, the plug is indeed a 2 prong.

Smart and safe or ignorant and dangerous?

Sandy.
 
Ex-Moderator
Joined 2002
Sandy,

The fuse is a separate issue. It is there mostly to protect the equipment from damage (if sized correctly). Phil explains the typical fault modes for a short in a metal box. The plastic box will certainly eliminate most possible ways of getting a shock from your PSU. That said, equipment sold retail with two-prong-plugs will come with a warning that it is to be serviced only by a qualified person. Therefore when you open your plastic box to do your DIY thing you take on the responsibility of possible electrocution.

Can you get shocked from your input and output connectors with the plastic case closed? Yes, if the hot AC accidentally shorts to one of the connectors. Is it like to happen? Probably not, but then again, it probably couldn’t get UL approval either.
 
haldor said:
About your outlet not having a ground. Unless your house is very old, you most likely have a ground present in the outlet box. Older house wiring (pre-Romex) mostly used a two conductor cable inside of a flexible metal jacket. The metal jacket of the cable is your earth ground and it is terminated to the outlet box.

The simplest solution to your problem in this case is to use one of the 3 to 2 prong adapters and install it according to directions (connect the adapter ground wire or tab to the outlet cover screw which is grounded). I would prefer to replace the 2 prong outlets with 3 prong outlets and connect the outlet ground to the outlet box, but do this only if you know what you are doing.

If your house is really ancient, then it may not have grounded outlet boxes, in which case hire an electrician to install a proper circuit and outlet for your amp.

You can test for a grounded outlet box with an AC voltmeter. Measure between the hot and neutral and you should see around 120 VAC (US). Meter between the cover screw and the hot and you should also see around 120 V. Between the neutral and the cover screw should be less than 1 volt. If your box is not grounded then you will probably measure around 60 volts between the Hot and cover screw and 60 volts between the neutral and cover screw.

Phil

My humblest appologies. I just noticed you are located in Belgium. All of my comments about standard electical practices are based on my experiance in the USA. I have no idea things are done in Belgium. You need to talk to someone who is knowledgable about your country's electrical practices.

One comment, I have noticed that some European power plugs (French I believe) are round with two prongs and an recess on the edge of the plug. This recess is where the ground connection is made. It is possible your amp has a ground connection even though you only see 2 pins in the outlet. Again, don't take my word for it, check this with an electrician in your country.

Phil
 
An addendum regarding North American mains based on my own experience:

Don't assume that even a new house is wired correctly. This especially if it was built during a housing boom or part of a tract that went up fast. I have found the following in my place:

A- In a couple of wall sockets the ground was not wired correctly (i.e. an open ground).

B- Hot and neutral reversed.

One was sloppiness in construction the other was due to the previous owner doing his own "handyman" installations. Of course this is not supossed to happen if everybody follows the rules - but a fat lot of good that does me from the grave. So I check evey outlet in my house. Trust no one!

Also it is appearentlt legal to omit the ground if a GFI socket is used. Maybe this is OK but I still don't like depending soley on a circuit to detect a ground fault based on ME serving as the low impedance path to ground!

The moderator correct me if I'm wrong - one precaution against hot and neutral being reversed is to use a DPDT or DPST power switch when I buld something plus fusing both entry lines.
 
Kilowatski wrote: "Not true, the reason is about 9 posts back."
Are you responding to my post? If so, which part is not true?

I'm dense, so even though I check back about 9 posts, I didn't see the connection. I saw something about GFI but that didn't seem to relate closely to my comments. And nothing about DPDT power switches.:scratch: :scratch: :scratch:
 
Ex-Moderator
Joined 2002
sam9 said:
The moderator correct me if I'm wrong - one precaution against hot and neutral being reversed is to use a DPDT or DPST power switch when I buld something plus fusing both entry lines.
Hi Sam,

Your not wrong, but that won't cut it for many electrical inspectors. In some cities where inspection are required to sell a house or for new construction, or in the case of an FHA sale, the inspector will insist that Hot is Hot and Neu is Neu and all Grounds pins make to Ground. But yes, a DP switch will insure the Hot is disconnected, just don't switch the Ground.
 
Old ground sheme:

I’ve been considering this old system for my new upgraded grounding:
 

Attachments

  • grounded vampire.jpg
    grounded vampire.jpg
    39.9 KB · Views: 150
Rodd & Kilowatt,

It's true that inspectors will insist on hot ant neutral being correct, however, in my area (Silicon Valley) resales don't require inspection unless the lender insists. So the previous owner can do all kind of dumb things. In fact, even in new construction, especially tracts and condo developments, I think the inspectors often rely on the "profesional expertise" of the contractor and the lead electrician -- "if he's from the union it must be right". When construction is booming, there just aren't enough inspectors. And the actual construction is often done by less skilled workmen presumed to be under the supervision of someone who knows the code. A local electrician told me once that he makes a good living correcting the wiring on 2-10 year old condos!

Anyway, I continue to trust no one and check all outlets personally.

BTW, a couple of decades ago I worked for company making spectrometers -- they once (on advice from lawyers) had to recall hundreds of units that were perfectly ok per UL in order to refit them with DPDT power switches. They discovered faculty and grad students had a tendancy to do DIY lab remodeling and couldn't be relied on to do the wiring right way round.
 
Ok, this seems like an appropiate place for this question.

I recently finished building a Leach Amp and am putting it in an all aluminum enclosure. Currently, the chassis is grounded to AC earth via 3 prong plug. Unfortunatly, since I moved into the dorm at college, the room only has 2 prong outlets. (although the room next door has 3 prong, wierd) Any suggestons on what the safest way to run this would be? I currently have it connected through a power bar (with surge protection) and a 3-prong to 2-prong adapter.

I figure I should probably ask, since I don't really want to kill any of my suitemates :rolleyes:

BTW, occasionally I get a small shock from the thing, although I think its static cause if I touch a doorknob first I don't get shocked :)
 
Oh, I almost forgot. The power bar I am using has a ground indicator light that comes on if I finagle the plug in the wall socket a bit. But I turns off as soon as I quit pressing.

Is this really indicating that I have a ground path. Can 2 prong plugs have a return to ground?

-Wes
 
Ex-Moderator
Joined 2002
wrl said:
Ok, this seems like an appropiate place for this question.

I recently finished building a Leach Amp and am putting it in an all aluminum enclosure. Currently, the chassis is grounded to AC earth via 3 prong plug. Unfortunatly, since I moved into the dorm at college, the room only has 2 prong outlets. (although the room next door has 3 prong, wierd) Any suggestons on what the safest way to run this would be? I currently have it connected through a power bar (with surge protection) and a 3-prong to 2-prong adapter.

I figure I should probably ask, since I don't really want to kill any of my suitemates :rolleyes:

BTW, occasionally I get a small shock from the thing, although I think its static cause if I touch a doorknob first I don't get shocked :)


wrl said:
Oh, I almost forgot. The power bar I am using has a ground indicator light that comes on if I finagle the plug in the wall socket a bit. But I turns off as soon as I quit pressing.

Is this really indicating that I have a ground path. Can 2 prong plugs have a return to ground?

-Wes
Wes,

Even the two prong adaptors have a grounding tab that can be screwed to the cover plate screw. I cannot tell you to just use the two prong adaptor as this is unsafe even though many people use them.
 
Status
This old topic is closed. If you want to reopen this topic, contact a moderator using the "Report Post" button.