ELNA for Audio real or fake

Status
This old topic is closed. If you want to reopen this topic, contact a moderator using the "Report Post" button.
Hi, In my naivety i also purchased 8 so called Elna For Audio caps.
These came from a HK ebay seller that assured me they where !00% Authentic Elna.

Judge for yourself?

Thanks
 

Attachments

  • Elna ebay  1.jpg
    Elna ebay 1.jpg
    391.8 KB · Views: 742
  • Elna ebay  2.jpg
    Elna ebay 2.jpg
    552.7 KB · Views: 711
  • Elna ebay  3.jpg
    Elna ebay 3.jpg
    711 KB · Views: 685
  • Elna ebay  4.jpg
    Elna ebay 4.jpg
    271 KB · Views: 642
  • Elna ebay  5.jpg
    Elna ebay 5.jpg
    307.3 KB · Views: 629
  • Elna ebay  6.jpg
    Elna ebay 6.jpg
    151.1 KB · Views: 299
My 2 cents:
Instead of going for the specially made for audio kind of stuff, which have gold print and double price ....
Choose ones which is made for SMPS purpose, long life.
Example: Digikey has an Cornell Dubilier Electronics 63V/6800uF ERS=44mOhm and max ripple at 5.55 A @20kHz!! and 3000h. Price 6$
In comparison the ELNA LAO 63V/6800uF is only rated at 4.38A @ 20kHz ... no ERS rating. 1000h rating!
Genuine caps for SMPS in almost all cases will be better than made for audio stuff. The worst environment for a cap will be an SMPS having constant high ripple current and very high switching frequencies.
.... so why end up with even bad fake ones?
/Baldin
 
My 2 cents:
Instead of going for the specially made for audio kind of stuff, which have gold print and double price ....
Choose ones which is made for SMPS purpose, long life.
Example: Digikey has an Cornell Dubilier Electronics 63V/6800uF ERS=44mOhm and max ripple at 5.55 A @20kHz!! and 3000h. Price 6$
In comparison the ELNA LAO 63V/6800uF is only rated at 4.38A @ 20kHz ... no ERS rating. 1000h rating!
Genuine caps for SMPS in almost all cases will be better than made for audio stuff. The worst environment for a cap will be an SMPS having constant high ripple current and very high switching frequencies.
.... so why end up with even bad fake ones?
/Baldin

I totally agree. Don't go for the fancy gold printed labels, instead do some research and find some 'good' capacitors :)
 
Status
This old topic is closed. If you want to reopen this topic, contact a moderator using the "Report Post" button.