diyAudio

diyAudio (http://www.diyaudio.com/forums/)
-   Multi-Way (http://www.diyaudio.com/forums/multi-way/)
-   -   Any Experience with Troels Gravesen Designs??? (http://www.diyaudio.com/forums/multi-way/86890-any-experience-troels-gravesen-designs.html)

mlammert 21st September 2006 03:12 PM

Any Experience with Troels Gravesen Designs???
 
Hi all,

First, thank you for all the replies that I got from my first post regarding good first projects... Probably the best advise I received was to not skimp too much on the first project -- really do a good bang-for-the-investment project... I like that idea...

I have been searching for pretty much complete plans and consturction diary type web sites and many people suggested Troels Gravesen (http://www.troelsgravesen.dk/Diy_Lou...r_Projects.htm) and Tony Gee (http://www.humblehomemadehifi.com/)...

I like Tony Gee's designs but they are a bit pricy for my very first ever project... And, it seems that a lot of assumptions are made throughout the plans and write-ups... :confused: I am not experienced enough right now to make assumptions and feel I need more specific plans...

So, I really like Troels' web site and the overall price and write-ups seem right on par with what I am looking at for a first project and my experience level... :D

http://www.troelsgravesen.dk/Diy_Lou...r_Projects.htm

My question is:
Does anybody have personal experience constructing any of these projects and if so, could you give some advise and opinions on why you chose one particular project by Troels over a different one???

My preferences:
1) I think I want a 3-way (or more) system... Do not want to be dependent on a sub right now... I like the floorstander designs...

2) This will only be for true stereo listening...

3) I listen to a lot of female vocals (Paula Cole, Tori Amos, Smoosh, Tera MacLean, Charllotte Martin, etc)... Not into pop but like some rock an droll and classic rock... Do not listen to classical... Little jazz... Little heavy metal (Tool, NIN)...

4) The original listen room will be small... 10wide x 12deep x 8high
It has one window (10' wall) and one door (other 10' wall)...

One last thing:
Any recommendations on CD Player/Pre-Amp/Amps would also be appreciated... This is truly my first system (entirely)...

Thanks agian everyone,
Mark

mlankton 21st September 2006 03:59 PM

I don't think you can do any better than Troel's designs. If Troel's were working commercially he would probably be regarded as one of the top speaker designers.
Just remember about Troel's projects: most of them are 4 ohm and relatively low sensitivity, so make sure your amp is up to snuff if you have your heart set on one of his speakers.

tktran303 21st September 2006 04:29 PM

Troels has a very nice website with lots of pictures, good documentation, with many many projects to try.

Many are not optimised to the n-th degree, but is still better than many other projects out there in free-to-DIY land

You could do a lot worse.

Don't get into the trap of throwing money away at expensive drivers, only to use off-the-shelf crossovers, online calculators, or start off with a one-size-fits-all crossover like the AR series XO and tweak til the cows come home (absolutely no measurement equipment=shooting in the dark til you get it right)

Landroval 21st September 2006 06:15 PM

For lower cost and great value check out also projects by John Krutke:
http://www.zaphaudio.com/

ScottG 21st September 2006 06:46 PM

http://www.troelsgravesen.dk/PMS.htm

This is the design I most often recomend here..

Its a very good design AND the documentation is prob. the best you'll find. I'd change ALL the capacitors however, to SA grade Clarity Caps (which provide the best sound for the money).

http://www.e-speakers.com/products/claritycap.htm

.................................................. .................................................. ..

as to other components..

DIY:

Source: Squeezbox2 and

http://diyparadise.com/dackit/1545bdackit.html

Volume control:

http://www.intactaudio.com/atten.html

Amplifer:

http://www.twistedpearaudio.com/

.................................................. ..............................................

Or purchased (non-diy) equipment:

Source:

http://www.6moons.com/audioreviews/raysonic/cd128.html

Integrated Amp:

http://www.6moons.com/audioreviews/redwine4/30.html

kyselym 21st September 2006 08:36 PM

can't help to write st.

if you are going to build your first equip. I suggest to start with something easy and relatively cheap.
as for speakers (cheaper ones):
you could try:
Tony G's DD8mk-II in close box and add L26 as subs (2.5way design)
or
Roman Bednarek's alpheus
http://www.rjbaudio.com/Alpheus/alpheus.html
or
Troels PMS
http://www.troelsgravesen.dk/PMS.htm

I own the first one (tony's) and it sounds really good. Would like to try Troels (to comapre soft cones with Al)but not sure if 22cm driver would satisfy me...maybe there will be some bigger brother later :)

as for other equip. don't spend so much money its not worth. NAD power amp and preamp will perform very well or you can try www.aldax.cz they are cheep and very good(like NAD) pages are in CZ but they also speak english. just look for "Login, Kontakty" there is email.

don't let low powers of aldax modules fool you it's just because their 50w is true sine power and this amp will play much louder than any comercial designs you could buy. I own SPV100P and they are great amps! aprox. $130 for 2xSpv100P + toroid (protections are included) but would recomend SPM100 or 250 for begginer (but a bit more expensive) for more info you can contact me on email(subject: Aldax)

ocaukrell 22nd September 2006 12:14 AM

As a starter my suggestion is,
start with troels sp95's, fairly cost effective and easy to build.
Use cheapish bits for the cabinet and xover, I dont believe it will make a big difference.

Wait for it . . . .

the reason I say use cheapish bits is that after you have built these, you will have a fair idea of how they will perform.
A trial speaker if you will.
Then move onto his ekta's reuse the drivers from the sp95's and throw the rest out.
It's what I did.

the ektas are faily more expensive due to the midrange, but they are so far ahead. I also love female vocals (Kate bush)

See link in sig or search here for ekta.......

andy2 23rd September 2006 04:01 AM

It depends on your tastes. I've built about 3 pairs of speakers based on his design. On most of his speakers, especially the early designs, they tend to be laid back and voiced for easy listening. His design tends to be very balanced and the sound has an even-handed characteristic and good for long term listening. He did modified some of his earlier designs such as the AcapellaSeas and TJL into more neutral voicing. Basically, most of his design frequency response, they tend to have a 1db dip in the critical midrange for easy listening. You also notice that the freq. response has a gradual decrease from the bass to the high freq.

But having said that, all of his speakers are very carefully designed. After listening to his speakers for awhile, there is something right about the way they sound. If you want to know how his speaker sound like, you could audition speakers from Viena Acoustic since they have a similar sound, at least that is how I feel.

I am a regular visitor of his website and I feel like his designs are more and more complete. And from reading his documentation, his latter designs are perhaps a bit more complete, and sophisticated than his earlier designs. I would recommend some of his latter designs such as the TJL3, PMS, AcapellaSeas, and the Stradivari clone.

andy2 23rd September 2006 04:32 AM

Quote:

Originally posted by mlankton
I don't think you can do any better than Troel's designs. If Troel's were working commercially he would probably be regarded as one of the top speaker designers.
Just remember about Troel's projects: most of them are 4 ohm and relatively low sensitivity, so make sure your amp is up to snuff if you have your heart set on one of his speakers.

I feel like I have to make a correction for the impedance. I think most of his designs have very friendly impedance and usually at abot 8ohm.

and I think in term of sensitivity, he designs are just like most of commercial designs.

seve 23rd September 2006 10:03 AM

I have heard a few of Troels' creations and overall I really like the general signature/sound they present.

I have heard the following models:

Proac 2.5 and 2.95.
SP95 (only heard shortly)
Point75A -> Point75I (My present speaker build by TG)
Acapella SE
PMS
And perhaps a few more for a short periode.

I really like all of the above speakers and you can do a lot worse, though if I was to build a speaker today I would probably pick the PMS.......Though I am not sure I could ever sell the Point75I

Martin


All times are GMT. The time now is 12:37 PM.


vBulletin Optimisation provided by vB Optimise (Pro) - vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2014 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.
Copyright 1999-2014 diyAudio


Content Relevant URLs by vBSEO 3.3.2