I am building a 3-way speaker using a 10" woofer that plays from 28-2500Hz, a Vifa P11WH-00-08 mid and Vifa D19TD tweeter.
I would like to know what to consider in choosing the right slope and frequencies for the crossover. The response and impedance graphs are provided for the vifa drivers, however I have no such information for the woofer, and I understand the voice coil inductance, Le, is important and that figure is not provided. Is it necessary to test the woofer with software if I don't have the Le value?
Any insight into the design of the crossover post-knowing the slope and frequencies desired would be fantastic, I know a lot of questions are asked about crossover design and I hope I'm not repeating other peoples enquiries. I've just had a hard time getting my head around how to actually smooth out impedance curves and response curves for the drivers.
Basically I have the box designed and ready to go, now I need to design the crossovers. BTW I hope I can get away with a 12db/octave slope as I think the usable frequency range between each of the drivers is very high.
Thanks ~Andrew
I would like to know what to consider in choosing the right slope and frequencies for the crossover. The response and impedance graphs are provided for the vifa drivers, however I have no such information for the woofer, and I understand the voice coil inductance, Le, is important and that figure is not provided. Is it necessary to test the woofer with software if I don't have the Le value?
Any insight into the design of the crossover post-knowing the slope and frequencies desired would be fantastic, I know a lot of questions are asked about crossover design and I hope I'm not repeating other peoples enquiries. I've just had a hard time getting my head around how to actually smooth out impedance curves and response curves for the drivers.
Basically I have the box designed and ready to go, now I need to design the crossovers. BTW I hope I can get away with a 12db/octave slope as I think the usable frequency range between each of the drivers is very high.
Thanks ~Andrew
Measure! 
All the driver's responses will be different now they are mounted on a baffle. This needs to be taken into account when crossover designing.
You have the right idea about picking smooth parts of the frequency response curve to use for crossing over, but you also need to take into account the smoothness of the phase and impedance curves, as well as any attenuation required to match levels.
All the driver's responses will be different now they are mounted on a baffle. This needs to be taken into account when crossover designing.
You have the right idea about picking smooth parts of the frequency response curve to use for crossing over, but you also need to take into account the smoothness of the phase and impedance curves, as well as any attenuation required to match levels.
Hi,
Regarding the woofer, measure the dc resistance of the voice coil, Re. Then connect a zobel network (R in series with C) in paralell with the woofer, making R=Re and choosing C in order to get a flat impedance characteristic, but you will allways need to measure !!!
The Vifa P11 has a smooth response, and I would try to cross it as high as possible, perhaps using a 1st order network (again, with impedance compensation). I dont´t know the tweeter, so I make no ideia how it sounds...
Final: Why not use an active crossover for the woofer ? It would solve a lot of problems...
Good work!
Regarding the woofer, measure the dc resistance of the voice coil, Re. Then connect a zobel network (R in series with C) in paralell with the woofer, making R=Re and choosing C in order to get a flat impedance characteristic, but you will allways need to measure !!!
The Vifa P11 has a smooth response, and I would try to cross it as high as possible, perhaps using a 1st order network (again, with impedance compensation). I dont´t know the tweeter, so I make no ideia how it sounds...
Final: Why not use an active crossover for the woofer ? It would solve a lot of problems...
Good work!
What is the 10" woofer you are using.
I'd agree that an active for the woofer is going to be the best option.
If you find that active is not possible then design a crossover for the tweeter and mid just as you would for a 2-way with the mid allowed to roll off naturally at the bottom end as the P11's are smooth rolling off, then arm yourself with a bunch of inductors to try and blend in the woofer using a 1st order.
Have a look at your mid's response and look for where the mid is about 3dB down and use that as a starting point for your woofer crossover..... use about 7ohms (for a 8ohm woofer) to work out an inductor. Test, test and test.
You've picked a hard one but good luck and have fun with it. BTW, the P11 mid deserves an better tweeter than the D19TD IMO and a D27TG would be a better choice...... just an opinion.
I'd agree that an active for the woofer is going to be the best option.
If you find that active is not possible then design a crossover for the tweeter and mid just as you would for a 2-way with the mid allowed to roll off naturally at the bottom end as the P11's are smooth rolling off, then arm yourself with a bunch of inductors to try and blend in the woofer using a 1st order.
Have a look at your mid's response and look for where the mid is about 3dB down and use that as a starting point for your woofer crossover..... use about 7ohms (for a 8ohm woofer) to work out an inductor. Test, test and test.
You've picked a hard one but good luck and have fun with it. BTW, the P11 mid deserves an better tweeter than the D19TD IMO and a D27TG would be a better choice...... just an opinion.
rabbitz I am using the Jaycar response 10" woofer. Basically I want to build this setup with existing parts without having to buy new ones. I have a pair of jaycar response tweeters I wanted to switch out for vifa's to match the vifa mids better, but if I can get away with what I have with little difference I'll just stick with that. I don't have much specs on those jaycars though. I have also been under the impression that those tweeters aren't very good but I think thats due to stereotypical opinion. It's definitely going to be 3-way without the active woofer.
Thanks for everyone elses comments
~Andrew
Thanks for everyone elses comments
~Andrew
OK........ the Jaycar woofer is the CW2137? It's got quite a high sensitivity which could work in your favour for BSC if you crossover at about 350Hz or a bit lower for a 300mm wide baffle.
If you've got all those drivers, then that's what you use. You could try both tweeters and I think the Jaycar (CT2010) ones might out do the D19TD (have a look at the D19TD response which I never thought was correct as it looks more like a mid..... comments anyone on the D19TD as it has me puzzled).
Good luck and get into it.
If you've got all those drivers, then that's what you use. You could try both tweeters and I think the Jaycar (CT2010) ones might out do the D19TD (have a look at the D19TD response which I never thought was correct as it looks more like a mid..... comments anyone on the D19TD as it has me puzzled).
Good luck and get into it.
Tom, series or parallel, no -- one does not do so
JE's T/S specs. have lots of errors. Acoustic output / watt input isn't really that useful as almost all amplifiers are voltage sources. Assuming the basic T/S specs for the CW2137 are correct, the particular woofer only has a voltage sensitivity of 87dB/2.83Vrms/1m. Like what the others have said, measure-measure-measure!
swin1, the mids will need a rumble filter or they'll be easily damaged by bassy software [not to mention they'll also sound bad].
Cheers!
JE's T/S specs. have lots of errors. Acoustic output / watt input isn't really that useful as almost all amplifiers are voltage sources. Assuming the basic T/S specs for the CW2137 are correct, the particular woofer only has a voltage sensitivity of 87dB/2.83Vrms/1m. Like what the others have said, measure-measure-measure!
swin1, the mids will need a rumble filter or they'll be easily damaged by bassy software [not to mention they'll also sound bad].
Cheers!
- Status
- This old topic is closed. If you want to reopen this topic, contact a moderator using the "Report Post" button.