Wide-band Dipole Project

Status
This old topic is closed. If you want to reopen this topic, contact a moderator using the "Report Post" button.
Jump to Latest
D

DougL

Member
Joined 2004
I want to try a Dipole speaker with a "full-range" driver augmented as required.

My goals are:
Low distortion Drivers / Low distortion Speaker.
95 db capability with 10 db overhead
Moderate cost, say less than $500 US.
No crossover 300 to 3k, hopefully 200 to 4k.
Active crossover (Behringer DCX2496) with Gainclone amps.

I am looking at the AURA NS3-193-8A in a MTMWW.
Link to NS3

Positives: 100 Hz to 10 kHz response.
Under 1% distortion at all frequency’s of interest.
5 MM x-max allows 109 db for a pair at 200 Hz. (.5m baffle)

For a Tweeter, I am proposing the B&G NEO3
Link to NEO3
However, I am considering 3/4" and 1" dynamic tweeters as well.
Since the crossover isn’t required to be less than 2k, I am open to less conventional choices .

For a woofer, the Dayton 10" RS looks good.
Link to DAYTON RS270S-8 10"

I was looking for community input before buying the drivers.
I have started buying crossover parts and amps.

Thanks in advance:

Doug
 
tg3

tg3

Member
Joined 2002
Not sure you can get to 105 dB peak with the NS3 (80 dB), even when paired. And certainly not with chip amps.

Another consideration for the fullrange is the WR125S from Creative Sound Solutions.


An externally hosted image should be here but it was not working when we last tested it.



The Daytons look like a safe pick. How are you going to mount the woofers? An H-frame will not go up high enough for your fullrange choice.

Tweeters are dealers choice.
 
D

DougL

Member
Joined 2004
TG3;

Another consideration for the fullrange is the WR125S from Creative Sound Solutions
Click to expand...
Nice Driver, very nice driver.

Not sure you can get to 105 dB peak with the NS3 (80 dB), even when paired. And certainly not with chip amps.
Click to expand...

I was basing my assumptions on something I found on SL's site.

The SS specification is 90 dB SPL for a single 21W/8554 driver. For two drivers in parallel add 6 dB and for rear radiation reinforcement from the open baffle add another 6 dB, which explains the high measured value.
Click to expand...

Linkwitz Lab Models page

Given the NS3's 81 db sensitivity, add 9 db, 6 db for rear radiation, 3 db for double the area. That comes out about 90 db 1 watt. That should work out to 105 db with 32 watts.

Have I misinterpreted what I read, or is this not applicable? Its always a possibility.

I also ran SL's X-max calculator, and came up with 109 db at X-max with a .5 M baffle and 2 drivers.

How are you going to mount the woofers? An H-frame will not go up high enough for your fullrange choice.
Click to expand...
I was thinking of an 18" flat floor-standing baffle, possibly with a shallow U or H. I was envisioning something like the AVRO.

Thanks for your comments.

Doug
 
D

DougL

Member
Joined 2004
Elias;

If you are interested in wide-band speakers, you might want to consider Beyma full range drivers e.g. 12AG100. SPL and distorsion should be no problemo in >200Hz even in dipole. You can also cross it over well beyond 4kHz.
Click to expand...

Too many choices. :)

planet10;

Have a look at the Visaton B200... you can actually get away with no help on either end and add bits as you need.
Click to expand...

Those would be grand with the Pentode Amp/ Transconductance Amp you were talking about. :)

Thank you both. And I thought I read the Full Range Forum. :)
 
tg3

tg3

Member
Joined 2002
Originally posted by DougL
Given the NS3's 81 db sensitivity, add 9 db, 6 db for rear radiation, 3 db for double the area. That comes out about 90 db 1 watt. That should work out to 105 db with 32 watts....

I also ran SL's X-max calculator, and came up with 109 db at X-max with a .5 M baffle and 2 drivers.
Click to expand...
Well, a good spreadsheet beats a (semi)educated guess anyday. :blush:

Remember, on the SL spreadsheet D is the effective path difference, which is 1/2 the baffle width. So D=0.25 for a 20" (0.5M) baffle. After you add 6dB for radiation into half-space, you can go down to about 150 Hz. But I bet the WR125S will be much cleaner near xmax. :nod:
Originally posted by DougL
I was thinking of an 18" flat floor-standing baffle, possibly with a shallow U or H. I was envisioning something like the AVRO.
Click to expand...

Should work fine. With 2 RS270S, you should get down to about 80 Hz @ 105 dB with a 26" baffle (18" with 4" wings). You had planned on a subwoofer, right? :D

We're working on a similar design. I've chosen PHL drivers for the mid and woofer because of their high efficiency.
 
D

DougL

Member
Joined 2004
Remember, on the SL spreadsheet D is the effective path difference, which is 1/2 the baffle width. So D=0.25 for a 20" (0.5M) baffle. After you add 6dB for radiation into half-space, you can go down to about 150 Hz. But I bet the WR125S will be much cleaner near xmax.
Click to expand...
Good catch on D. Thanks. I guess I need to re-run the spreadsheet.
I suffer from an acute form of male pattern cheapness, so a $20 driver appeals to me. However, I agree your choice looks better. :)
I was also looking at the 4" Aura NS4-255-8D1,which would give me a bit more headroom, but there are no distortion or frequency response data available.
With 2 RS270S, you should get down to about 80 Hz @ 105 dB with a 26" baffle (18" with 4" wings).
Click to expand...
I like the way you think. I thought it would be more like 60 Hz with the 6db gain for half space, but I need to re-run those numbers, too.
You had planned on a subwoofer, right?
Click to expand...
I am planning a IB sub in a 4' by 5' by 12' insulated Storage behind the stairway. But I plan to finish the speakers first.

Thanks for your response. Please keep me posted on your progress.

Doug
 
R

reins

Member
Joined 2004
Hi,

I have great expierence with usher 8137 as midrange. I use the peak at 3,5kHz to extend the drivers range to 4kHz. How is it done? I cross over at 2,5kHz 2nd order LR and cross the tweeter (ribbon) at 4k with 4th order LR.

This sounds great. The lower crossover is 160Hz. With the 8" Usher driver output capability is not an issue, beaming might be but I found no problems here by listening.

Stephan
 
D

DougL

Member
Joined 2004
interesting...so did you ever get past prototyping these? and if so, how'd they sound?
Click to expand...
I am in the process of building them now.
I plan to have them finished by DIY Chicago Next month.
I changed the Midrange to a single SEAS MP 14 RCY/P for the final design. Now if I can get my measurement system running. :)
Got to love SoundEasy. :)

I am also taking the proto's to DIY Chicago.
It’s interesting what $50 in drivers can sound like.

Doug
 
Status
This old topic is closed. If you want to reopen this topic, contact a moderator using the "Report Post" button.
Top Bottom