diyAudio

diyAudio (http://www.diyaudio.com/forums/)
-   Multi-Way (http://www.diyaudio.com/forums/multi-way/)
-   -   WIN ISD Pro and multiway design (http://www.diyaudio.com/forums/multi-way/229040-win-isd-pro-multiway-design.html)

Stevenn 31st January 2013 06:20 AM

WIN ISD Pro and multiway design
 
HI all

As a newcomer to speaker design, I have downloaded WIN ISD Pro. It is a powerful tool and has helped me understand the physics of how speakers and drivers work.
But I have one question which I hope is not too dumb... :confused:

How do you use WIN ISD (and other programmes)to design muti-way speakers?

The programme sizes cabinets for individual drivers. Do you sum the cabinet volumes for each driver or is the definitive volume that of the largest driver as the drivers can share volume?

Thanks

Steve
Sydney, Australia

MikeCobar 31st January 2013 11:12 AM

G'day Steve, from 700km to the west of you (still in NSW though, Broken Hill's another 440km away).

I'm not at all knowledgeable about speaker building, although I did put together a 3-way last winter. In a 3-way where the woofer is ported, you have one "chamber" for that, and a separate chamber for the mid. My cabinet has a 3.6l sealed section for the 5.25" mid, while the 8" woofer more-or-less has the rest of the 68l or so, less internal bracing and the dimensions of the mid sealed section. The tweeter can "share" with the woofer as far as I know but it does depend on the type of tweeter, so it doesn't necessarily need a chamber of its own. My cab is TMW but MTW is also entirely possible (and common, I guess). I preferred to get the tweeter up to somewhere near ear height while seated as opposed to the tweet on my old Wharfedales pointing at my navel:wave2s:

I guess it's possible to have a ported mid as well, obviously with a second port (or even sealed for both, depends on the drivers, of course). There are considerations about where the port goes (front or back) size/length etc which are beyond my abilities, I just used what the recipe said:) In any case, ports are poisonously expensive for us here in Oz (I've added PE $3 ones to my cart only to have freight go up by $20!) so it's either put up with ridiculous prices from UK or US or make your own, or try to find local stuff (Jaycar, although they're not cheap either). It's even expensive to send electrons to Oz, apparently, given ITunes' prices here:eek:

As I understand it you model each driver in WinISD (it should tell you whether sealed or ported etc is best for your driver) and build around those dimensions. BSC and crossover stuff is over my head, no doubt much more knowledgeable people will answer your question more fully when their time zone catches up with ours:)

tvrgeek 31st January 2013 07:58 PM

WinISD is only for modeling the cabinet loading of the driver. That's the first 5% of speaker design. Prototyping and measuring are next. That will get you to understand a single driver in a cabinet and how far off the models can be. Then on to crossovers and compensation networks.

You don't want your mid and woofer to share the cabinet. If using multiple identical woofers, yes they can share. I have never seen a reason for a ported mid. 99% of the time you would but them in a chamber that is too big so the cabinet does not load it at all. This is NOT an IB, but it works effectively the same as one. Most tweeters are already in a sealed cabinet. If not, then you have to isolate them too.

Where to start is really hard to describe. I guess I have been at it too long and when I started we didn't have PC based tools. We didn't have PC's. A program like Sound Easy has all the tools to design a speaker. It is expensive and you had better be an expert in designing a speaker before you would have a clue how to use it. Model software helps an engineer who knows what he is doing. It does not replace them.

I am not a fan of full range drivers, but that is a way to start. After understanding the box and how it relates to T/S parameters, yo then need to download the Edge ( also free) to understand baffle step and edge diffraction. Read Olson. So, with a single full range driver, you can learn all about the box and compensation networks before you get your head to explode with crossovers. I think if I were to lay out a course to teach, I would start with a full range that is ill behaved ( most are) and then beat it into submission, add a tweeter, then add a woofer. I think that could be taught in a year providing the students were already woodworkers and had a 2 year degree in electronics.

There is one and only one truth in speaker building: It depends

Stevenn 1st February 2013 03:14 AM

Thanks guys for your replies.

What has been throwing me is that my old 3 -way speakers have drivers sharing the same box, ie no separate compartments. But they sound ok to me....
Therefore I am interested in trying to at least optimise their performance to some extent.
I certainly do not presume to be an instant expert. I see that this could be a pursuit or passion that could take up a lot of my time, but I'm not sure if I want it to.
Kits may be the way to go....

MikeCobar: i have used PVC pipe for ports -orange conduit or small diameter PVC pressure pipe.A lot cheaper.

Cheers

Helmuth 1st February 2013 05:42 AM

In winisd pro you can also simulate the filter and see the group-delay change.

So when people say you can only model bass isn't true.

wintermute 1st February 2013 08:09 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Stevenn (Post 3351107)
Thanks guys for your replies.

What has been throwing me is that my old 3 -way speakers have drivers sharing the same box, ie no separate compartments. But they sound ok to me....

They aren't closed back mid's are they? I've had a few closed back ones in my old three ways over the years.

Certainly if they are normal drivers then they will tend to act as a passive radiator for the main bass drivers, which will change the tuning of the box, and also muddy up the midrange because the mid driver is getting interfered with by the bass. Have you got a picture of the mid drivers back?

Tony.

MikeCobar 1st February 2013 09:35 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Stevenn (Post 3351107)

MikeCobar: i have used PVC pipe for ports -orange conduit or small diameter PVC pressure pipe.A lot cheaper.

Cheers

Yeah, I've done the same, my first build with single Aura 3" just had 1" water pipe from local hardware store.

Stevenn 1st February 2013 09:38 AM

Wintermute:
Not sure what you mean by 'closed back mids'? They are a simple one chambered sealed box containing the three drivers (sealed until I cut a port opening in front).
Your explanation of possible interference makes perfect sense and is probably exactly what is happening. Sad part is that I have more than likely been listening to inaccurate sound for 30 years which makes me more determined to put it right.
Purchased 30 yrs ago from a now defunct music shop near cinemas on George St, Sydney...

wintermute 1st February 2013 10:17 AM

Something like this Massive Audio M8C - Close-Back Mid-Range Massive Audio Basically it has a completely enclosed back on it so that it doesn't need a separate enclosure. I had two types. Cheap polycone's with a steel sealed back (which were pretty awful) and some Phillips dome mids which had quite a decent sized chamber on the back.

It wasn't DME Hi-Fi was it? That is the only HI-FI shop that I can remember that was near the cinemas.... I think I bought a tape deck for my parents there :)

I lived with my (most certainly less than optimal) three ways for about 26 years before finishing my current speakers, and for a lot of that I thought that they were fantastic! It wasn't until I heard something really outstanding that I realised that they were far from great, it was just that I had never heard anything better (than them) before that!

Tony.

tvrgeek 1st February 2013 06:23 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Helmuth (Post 3351181)
In winisd pro you can also simulate the filter and see the group-delay change.

So when people say you can only model bass isn't true.

Yes, you can add filters, but this is nothing like the CAD programs for crossover design because this is predicting perfect acoustic response and perfect impedance. A real crossover design program works of the real measured acoustic response. Useless for crossover design IMHO. My standard tool for driver selection and box suitability.


All times are GMT. The time now is 10:50 PM.


vBulletin Optimisation provided by vB Optimise (Pro) - vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2014 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.
Copyright 1999-2014 diyAudio


Content Relevant URLs by vBSEO 3.3.2