dumb speaker/cap question

Status
This old topic is closed. If you want to reopen this topic, contact a moderator using the "Report Post" button.
There is a certain bookshelf speaker sys that some are recomending upgrading the tweeter to a particular high quality one and adding a 12uf cap to it.
My dumb question is, how would the cap be wired to the tweeter?

Go easy on me as I know next to nothing about crossovers etc. :confused:
 
Member
Joined 2011
Paid Member
First be very skeptical.
12uf @ 8Ω = 1650Hz = Blown up tweeter.
12uf @ 4Ω = 3300Hz = Blown up tweeter if the power is too high.
Most tweeters don't like getting pushed lower than 2000Hz @ 6db/octave slope (which is what you have with just a capacitor in series to the positive pole of the tweeter).
If the speaker has a second order crossover (Series Cap w/ Parallel Inductor to the tweeter) I would ONLY recommend a 4Ω tweeter.
The crossover point would be around 1700Hz.
There are many high quality 4Ω tweeters that will behave properly @ 1700Hz.
The second order crossover attenuates at 12db/octave.
This combined with most large dome tweeters' natural roll off can sometimes equal a third order (18db/octave) acoustic roll off.

Please get more information and pay very close attention to tweeter specifications before driving the speaker.
 
diyAudio Moderator
Joined 2008
Paid Member
You would connect the capacitor between the amp and one terminal of the tweeter. The other terminal of the tweeter would go straight to the amp. The cap would typically go to the positive terminal of the amp, but the polarity of the tweeter depends on what goes best (sounds best) and won't cause any damage if you get it wrong.

If others have said it sounds good then perhaps it does. You won't be able to get too loud with it but if you're unsatisfied you can always change things around.
 
Member
Joined 2011
Paid Member
This is a tweeter that you will crossover at 12db/octave and pray.
This tweeter has a 1350hz resonant frequency.
A safe rule of thumb is to double the resonant for 12db/octave and at least triple for 6db/octave.
With the crossover point at 2nd order Lw/Ri 1700Hz you might obtain close to a 18db/octave acoustic roll off and the tweeter may be OK.
But remember, a driver moves, woofers just move more.
When a driver reaches its resonant frequency it will move a much longer distance to recreate the same amount of sound.
When tweeters move too much they blow up.
If you want to try this just start with your amp at minimum volume and SLOWLY turn up the volume with your ear to the tweeter.
If you start to hear the slightest crackling STOP, driving a tweeter beyond this point may destroy it.
I personally have looked at this tweeter for two projects but neither crossed the tweeter below 3500Hz 2nd order Lw/Ri.
 
Last edited:
diyAudio Moderator
Joined 2008
Paid Member
What exactly do you want to know?

I once used tweeters this way (single capacitor within 3 octaves of fs). I wouldn't do it this way any more but it did hold a certain charm for me at the time. Tweeters need to be at the right level and using a resistor for this purpose is neither here nor there with regards to how it works... if you need it then you need it, and if you do then the capacitor may need to be adjusted to suit.

One thing I'd do if I were going this way again is to implement a resonance peak filter so that the impedance doesn't overwhelm the capacitor giving you a peak near resonance.
 
I have since learned that the 2way speaker in question just has a 3.3uf cap wired into the tweeter and the woofer runs its full freq with no crossover..... a very simple acoustic suspension sys.

Can this be why a 12uf cap was recomeded with this particular tweeter?
 
diyAudio Moderator
Joined 2008
Paid Member
It is a 4 ohm unit which broadly suggests any capacitor will be twice as large as an equivalent 8 ohm compatible capacitor.

If you like the sound of the woofer enough to work on this unit, you might check the damping inside the box, choose a crossover point and roll the woofer off a little. These issues and others are probably more of a concern than any worries about going second order with the tweeter.
 
Who are these 'some' people that recommended the upgrade ? :):rolleyes:
If you keep them at about 1 m from the walls , I may suggest ALSO to put
a rear tweeter on the cabinet . If you put two tweeters in series , for two 4Ω units you'll get the sum = 8 Ω ; so you may leave the previous capacitor :D
What about 'upgrading' the capacitor ?
Is it an electrolytic ( bipolar ) or film plastic )
:usd::rain:
 
Member
Joined 2011
Paid Member
I don't think he knows a lot about the speaker and he is looking for some simple help.

Next we need to know what the existing tweeter impedance is.
Is there any way you can remove the tweeter from the speaker and measure its Ω's out of circuit with your ohmmeter?
This will help us to determine the original C/O frequency of the tweeter.
 
I don't think he knows a lot about the speaker and he is looking for some simple help.

Next we need to know what the existing tweeter impedance is.
Is there any way you can remove the tweeter from the speaker and measure its Ω's out of circuit with your ohmmeter?
This will help us to determine the original C/O frequency of the tweeter.

It must be 4 ohms as it's a 8 ohm sys .....wired in parallell

BTW, The sys is a very cheap Dayton speaker It an acustic suspension (with a 6"woofer) and I just wanted to experiment with is as I like the size for my porpose (12" higjh) and I want to try an AS sys for the tighter mid bass. I would be using my sub with it. The tweeter is reported to be OK but, it can use some uprading.

The cheap polk speakers I'm now using is a rear ported sys and it has problems set in corners where I must position them.......the mid bass is muddled no mater what I do (due to the rear ports) short of cutting all the offending freqs.

So, basically, l just want to use the Dayton cabinet and woofer.
I seached the net and a couple of people said they used the tweeter in question as a replacement in the Dayton sys with excellent results so, I thought I would try it.
 
Last edited:
Member
Joined 2011
Paid Member
FWIW, two 4Ω speakers in parallel = 2Ω.
Two 4Ω drivers in series = 8Ω.

Two 8Ω drivers in parallel both with complementary crossovers have a nominal impedance of 8Ω.

Since your bass driver is running "fullrange" the voicecoil will still react with the tweeter it just wont supplement the sound in a significant way.
 
FWIW, two 4Ω speakers in parallel = 2Ω.
Two 4Ω drivers in series = 8Ω.

Yes, of course. I (embarrassingly) misspoke as I had recently woke up (I'm retired) and was nursing my morning coffee. :eek:

Anyway, I decided not to waste time with that cheap Dayton sys.
All is not lost however as I did learn a few things in this thread. Thanks! :)
 
Last edited:
Status
This old topic is closed. If you want to reopen this topic, contact a moderator using the "Report Post" button.