I'm building a rigid cone version of my dipole panel and decided to use Fountek FW146 and Vifa DQ25. While I immediately fall in love with FW146, the same cannot be said about the popular DQ25. It sounded "hard" for the lack of better word.
I suspected the phase shield is the issue and is a compromise between trying to maintain flat on-axis respose vs. other anomalies. So I removed one and measure it just to see.
On axis response
Measured from about 20cm on-axis, here we can see the effect of phase shield. It brought back the dip of typical rigid cone tweeter, but overall cannot remediate it fully. I'd say it's marginally useful.
Off-axis response
Things gets more interesting here. Now we see the compromise, which is poor off-axis response. No phase shield is better by miles.
Burst decay
This one is I think the real reason why original DQ25 won't sound smooth. It's all the resonances, stored energy, and reflection of that hard phase shield.
So I proceeded to remove all the phase shield of the 4 tweeters. The subjective impression is more mellow sounding tweeter and a bit loss of "immediacy" as in steel guitar strings
In case you want to try, be careful in removing the shield as it is very close to the cone. I managed to dent one of the 4 tweeters ...
I suspected the phase shield is the issue and is a compromise between trying to maintain flat on-axis respose vs. other anomalies. So I removed one and measure it just to see.
On axis response
Measured from about 20cm on-axis, here we can see the effect of phase shield. It brought back the dip of typical rigid cone tweeter, but overall cannot remediate it fully. I'd say it's marginally useful.
Off-axis response
Things gets more interesting here. Now we see the compromise, which is poor off-axis response. No phase shield is better by miles.
Burst decay
This one is I think the real reason why original DQ25 won't sound smooth. It's all the resonances, stored energy, and reflection of that hard phase shield.
So I proceeded to remove all the phase shield of the 4 tweeters. The subjective impression is more mellow sounding tweeter and a bit loss of "immediacy" as in steel guitar strings
In case you want to try, be careful in removing the shield as it is very close to the cone. I managed to dent one of the 4 tweeters ...