An oil type varnish or similar but not smell

[andy2]

I tried Formsby Tung Oil but that thing smells even after months, so could anyone recommend a type of oil finish that does not smell at least in the long run?
Has anyone tried Danish oil or Linseed oil before?

[kevinahcc20]

Danish oil works well and cures completely after a number of days so that odors will not be a long term issue. My preferred finish is Minwax Wipe-On Polyurethane which also cures completely and is odor free overnight - it is a forgiving finish and builds a nice depth with 4 to 6 coats and about 4 hours drying time between coats.

[andy2]

Originally Posted by kevinahcc20

Danish oil works well and cures completely after a number of days so that odors will not be a long term issue. My preferred finish is Minwax Wipe-On Polyurethane which also cures completely and is odor free overnight - it is a forgiving finish and builds a nice depth with 4 to 6 coats and about 4 hours drying time between coats.

Thanks. I might try out the Minwax Wipe-On Polyurethane. Wiping a finish probably is more convenient since I do not have any spraying equipment.

[speakerdoctor]

Danish oil is less smelly than linseed oil. Be aware that a wipe on urethane will pretty much seal the surface. If that's what you want, then fine. You won't need to oil ever again with urethane.

[andy2]

Originally Posted by speakerdoctor

Be aware that a wipe on urethane will pretty much seal the surface.

Won't be a problem.

[Andrew Eckhardt]

If you're going the polyurethane route, the Minwax product is petroleum based and will stink before it cures. But the stink is what saves you. Just do whatever it takes to not smell it and you're good.

Polyurethanes that thin and clean with water don't really stink but there's still major badness in the mix that you should not inhale (read MSDS for whatever you use), and since you can't smell it as easily you have to be more careful with it until it cures. :|

[kingfisher]

Okay this may seam a bit off the mark, but reading it may suggest otherwise! I found it after thinking the same of Watco Danish oils and google Lemon oil for furniture! This came up: Wax Protection for Furniture

Francis

[kevinahcc20]

kingfisher,

The article discusses how you feed or protect the finish layer & I would agree that a high quality paste wax is a fine choice, but not a substitute for the finish itself.

[speakerdoctor]

Originally Posted by kingfisher

Okay this may seam a bit off the mark, but reading it may suggest otherwise! I found it after thinking the same of Watco Danish oils and google Lemon oil for furniture! This came up: Wax Protection for Furniture

Francis

Notice the article says 'you CAN apply paste wax over...urethane'. I don't see the point if the surface is already sealed with urethane. I do see the point if the wood is not sealed with a hard finish like tung oil, urethane, etc... The wax then acts like a sealent, but doen't last like the hard finishes which is why you need to re-wax periodically.

[kingfisher]

I do not understand the point here, I only suggested that 'andy2' look into the possibility of wax as an alternative for finishing. But he did reply "Won't be a problem!" already! (andy2) are you amused with this and did you get your answer?
Francis