Midrange selection: Dayton RS52 vs. Peerless HDS 832873

[infinia]

Originally posted by tinitus
Tweeters have beaming issues as well

Yup mostly beyond hearing and no crossover problems up top. Problems being the mismatched driver directivity around the crossover region

[DcibeL]

I have to agree with Infinia on this one.

[rinx]

Hey!
I can make suggestion only about midrange. I am building 3 way system and have tested so far some mids:
-Vifa P13
-AUdax130
-Vifa PL14

I have crossed them all 2500hz with tweet 910821. So far it sound best to ears last combination with PL14. It is truly very musical, high end is very good and even it can pretty low. I need a crossover about 200Hz so thats why it works fo me very well. P13 does not have bass at all and its not so musical, littlevit muddy..
Audax is also good. I have listed drivers at least a month for each of them, it just takes time to notice all details! I prefer PL14.

[jerome69]

A DAYTON RS150 OR RS125 or RS100 for mid ?

[critofur]

Originally Posted by jerome69

A DAYTON RS150 OR RS125 or RS100 for mid ?

Of the RS drivers I like the RS225, RS100, and RS28. Don't care for the 125 looking at the charts - haven't heard it though.

Have seen several people that have done lots of building/testing/listening to speakers seem to really like the Peerless 832873.

Have seen some comments not liking the RS52 - I have heard designs in which I did not care for it either. I have not heard well respected designs such as Zaphs, which use the RS52, however.

Some of the best liked speakers use the Morel MDM55, have not heard the same negative comments about that as I have about the RS52.

I would like to hear the RS52 however, as it seems like a good value, well made.

Seems like the Peerless 832873 and the (relatively) new RS28F could be a very nice combination crossed 2nd order below 2Khz

A few different models of Peerless Nomex woofers seem to have made it into various veteran speaker guys favorite speakers (one reason why I bought a case of 10 of both the 5.25" and 6.5" ones when I found them at bargain "buyout" prices). I'm still pondering speaker design ideas and have a few of my first test boxes built - once the weather gets warmer, I'll get back into building...

Originally Posted by infinia

...Problems being the mismatched driver directivity around the crossover region

Some people have been trying the RS28F in waveguides with good results - you can see over on the techtalk board, or, look at Mark K's "Audio Heuristics" web page...

Originally Posted by rinx

...PL14. It is truly very musical, high end is very good and even it can pretty low....I prefer PL14.

Hmm, how about the PL11?

http://www.parts-express.com/pdf/299-227s.pdf

[Dr.EM]

This Tang Band may also be suitable for the original crossover points intended:

Parts-Express.com:Tang Band W4-1337SD 4" Titanium Driver | full range driver 4" woofer extended range driver tang band tb speakers tangband-41108

Good wide range, as used in the "Statements" DIY 3-way design

Statements


I use the Dayton RS52. I think it sounds great, very 'fast' and also very convincing on female vocals especially. Must be crossed more like 800Hz though, which means a lot of metal cone woofers will need active notch filters to control breakups in order to meet it. I use an M8a with active 24dB LR and notch filtering.