Hi-Vi W6, Silver flute W17RC38 or Dayton RS150s

[jomatecc]

I havent been in the speaker building for a while, need to make a decision between one of the following the Hi-Vi W6 , Silver flute W17RC38, or Dayton's RS150s I choose these because of the prices which will be almost three times by the times they are in my hands (custom and shipping) I really need some input from anyone who have had any experience with them especially the silverflute and Hi-Vi any suggestion will be welcome.

Thanks in advance

 

[Willitwork]

I'm not familiar with the Dayton but the Hi Vi W6 is said to be very similar to the ubiquitous Vifa P17 series, and it's not much cheaper either. In fact except for tweeters Hi Vi drivers are not what you'd consider a bargain anymore, many are definitely on the pricey side.

On the other hand the Silver Flute midbass driver is definitively a bargain, and on paper at least they are the best of the three drivers you mention. I have purchased a pair out of curiosity and was impressed at the build quality: sturdy cast basket, very large magnet, exotic wool fiber cone material. I haven't tried them in any project yet though.

 

[jupiterjune]

Are you building a two way speaker?

The RS150's are aluminum coned drivers -- and they do have that metal sound which I dislike (when used in a two way).

If you are using them as woofers in a 3 way, they work OK but don't go real deep.

JJ

 

[mcmahon48]

my choice would be the silver flutes

for the very flat response and at a decent level which is around 89 - 90 db crossover at 3khz if going 3 way find a good 4 inch mid and go with a vifa which can be found on ebay at a real low price right now but you will have to act fast

 

[chainenoble]

hi jomatecc,i built some mtm's with the silver flute's and a seas tweeter about 3 years ago.i'm very pleased with the sound and the bass output for this driver.they hold up well at higher volumes
too.infact,my wife perfers them over my all seas mtm that cost me 10 times as much.

 

[Willitwork]

Re: my choice would be the silver flutes

for the very flat response and at a decent level which is around 89 - 90 db crossover at 3khz if going 3 way find a good 4 inch mid and go with a vifa which can be found on ebay at a real low price right now but you will have to act fast

The D26 used to be Vifa's best tweeter imho, unfortunately it's become very difficult to find

 

[mcmahon48]

there has been a lot of them on ebay

I have looked a couple of times recently you have to enter just tweeter in ebay
hold on to your hat
I was able to buy 12 for 14 US plus shipping on ebay

 

[Geek]

I'm predjudiced in that SF are my new favorite woof for bookshelves.

So I vote Silver Flute

Cheers!

 

[jomatecc]

Thanks a lot guys

Thanks everyone your input is greatly appreciated, lost patience and Went with a Seas T14RCY/P-H 5.25" with the vifa xt25 and built a smaller bookshelf system which turned out very well. but I will use the Silver Flute for my next project now that I got some needed subjective input.

regards

 

[jomatecc]

silver flute w17RC38

Saw this review here http://www.stereomojo.com/Tanto Review/GemmeAudioTantoReview.htm which might be interesting to share.

Cheers