Bonded Logic Inc UltraSonic 12 Lining (A12P Pensils and Moosebox)

[mp9]

- would it be worth trying Bonded Logic Inc UltraSonic 12 in. x 12 in. Acoustic Panels?Bonded Logic Inc UltraSonic 12 in. x 12 in. Acoustic Panels (Package of 6)-60600-11212 at The Home Depot

Also wondering the general consensus on how many and much of the inner walls of the Standard A12P Pencil and Moosebox cabinets should be lined with the 1"x12"x12" panels?

And i'm not sure but i thought i read somewhere that Scott L. doesn't recommend any lining of the A12P standard Pencil cabinet, just stuffing, and vice versa for his "Moosebox" design, some clarification on that would be much appreciated.

 

[chrisb]

Looks to be very similar (other than the fabric backing) to the Ultra-touch 1/2" rolled produce we've used for several years now - and which appears to be NLA?

Scott would no doubt have particular reasons for his recommendations re lining or not of his various enclosure designs - I'd be inclined not to second guess on that subject.

 

[mp9]

Chris, the closest to that would be the .375" thick/radiant barrier http://http://www.homedepot.com/p/t/100656748?productId=100656748&storeId=10051&langId=-1&catalogId=10053&MERCH=REC%2d%5f%2dproduct%2d1%2d%5f%2d100661257%2d%5f%2d100656748%2d%5f%2dN#.Uc43bhZGxlI
...i have no idea how different it is from the other products. The 16 in. x 48 in. UltraTouch Denim Insulation Multi-Purpose Roll-60301-16482 at The Home Depot is the best buy but it's 2" thick! Again i'd guess it may be the same material as the .375" thick Radiant Barrier minus the barrier outer layer, i don't know?
I'd hate to think the much higher cost of the 12"x12" acoustic panels are all marketing, that would be seriously messed!

 

[Scottmoose]

You can try if you wish of course, but the pensils, being transmission lines, are specifically intended to be stuffed rather than lined, which can't provide the necessary amount of damping by itself.

 

[mp9]

Ok stuffing for the pencils makes sense that it's a transmission line. Specifically Wrt the Prncil's, i'm uncertain if it's a one or the other...or both line some or all walls then add the stuffing?

 

[Scottmoose]

the pensils, being transmission lines, are specifically intended to be stuffed rather than lined, which can't provide the necessary amount of damping by itself.

 

[mp9]

ok then

Thanks