diyAudio

diyAudio (http://www.diyaudio.com/forums/)
-   Markaudio (http://www.diyaudio.com/forums/markaudio/)
-   -   Enclosure decision???? (http://www.diyaudio.com/forums/markaudio/225789-enclosure-decision.html)

mikje 16th December 2012 01:45 AM

Enclosure decision????
 
I just ordered a pair of Alpair 10.2s and am now trying to decide which cabinet to build. I searched the forum for this, but haven't found anything that helps me. If there's another thread about this, please point me to it, and I apologize for posting a redundant issue.
I'm set up in a room that's about 16' X 16'. Wood floors, no wall hangings, minimal furniture. I usually listen at about 6-10 feet from the speakers. I have some leeway in how close I can put them to the wall; against the wall to about 2 feet out. I have a small sub, if I need it. They will flank a television, so they can be as close as 36 inches apart and as far as 6 feet apart. Only one corner available. My music taste is jazz, Steely Dan, Norah Jones, vocals, classical, classic rock, etc. About the only thing I don't listen to is any kind of metal or the like. WAF is not an issue; she knows I love this stuff and has no problem with me doing what I want (at least in MY listening room). So... floor standers or stand mounted are both fine.
I imagine any of the designs from the Markaudio website will sound great, but is there one that would suit my situation better than the others? I realize that's a subjective question, but I want to throw it out just the same.
Thanks in advance,
Mike

ssportclay 16th December 2012 02:02 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by mikje (Post 3286754)
I just ordered a pair of Alpair 10.2s and am now trying to decide which cabinet to build. I searched the forum for this, but haven't found anything that helps me. If there's another thread about this, please point me to it, and I apologize for posting a redundant issue.
I'm set up in a room that's about 16' X 16'. Wood floors, no wall hangings, minimal furniture. I usually listen at about 6-10 feet from the speakers. I have some leeway in how close I can put them to the wall; against the wall to about 2 feet out. I have a small sub, if I need it. They will flank a television, so they can be as close as 36 inches apart and as far as 6 feet apart. Only one corner available. My music taste is jazz, Steely Dan, Norah Jones, vocals, classical, classic rock, etc. About the only thing I don't listen to is any kind of metal or the like. WAF is not an issue; she knows I love this stuff and has no problem with me doing what I want (at least in MY listening room). So... floor standers or stand mounted are both fine.
I imagine any of the designs from the Markaudio website will sound great, but is there one that would suit my situation better than the others? I realize that's a subjective question, but I want to throw it out just the same.
Thanks in advance,
Mike

As far as free stuff goes, the Classic GR Mar-Ken 10.2 is probably a good bet for a stand mount bookshelf cabinet. The Pensil 10.2 is also popular for a floor stander.

Bob Brines 16th December 2012 02:21 AM

2 Attachment(s)
Well, if you are willing to pay me my plans fee, I have two very nice cabinets for the A10.2.

The first is a small BR -- 17"x8.5"x10.5" bottom ported and F3 ~40Hz. The picture is of the prototypes in raw plywood. I have the demo's in the paint shop as we speak. In natural cherry with a high gloss finish. Rather nice. Pictures in ~ a week.

The second is a MLTL -- 42"x8.5"x8.5" F3 ~35Hz. This is the demo I have been taking to shows. It is in a dark stained beech.

If you are interested, PM me.

Bob

doorman 16th December 2012 03:19 AM

1 Attachment(s)
You might also consider these. A very satisfying enclosure design from Dave @ planet10.
Taut, well controlled bass, stellar imaging, an all round great performer.
Happy hunting!
Don

mikje 16th December 2012 03:24 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by doorman (Post 3286803)
You might also consider these. A very satisfying enclosure design from Dave @ planet10.
Taut, well controlled bass, stellar imaging, an all round great performer.
Happy hunting!
Don

Are those plans available on his website? I didn't see them if they are. I like the looks of those, a lot. Your description sounds like just what I'm looking for.
Thanks,
Mike

doorman 16th December 2012 03:49 AM

Mike: E-mail Dave for plans.
david@planet10-hifi.com
Don

mikje 16th December 2012 03:53 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by doorman (Post 3286817)
Mike: E-mail Dave for plans.
david@planet10-hifi.com
Don

Thanks Don.

dekiller 23rd December 2012 06:41 PM

Go floorstanding plan.

skeeter99 23rd December 2012 07:18 PM

I listen to all those types of music and have 12's in the SuperPensil12 cabinets and thoroughly enjoy them. Plenty of bass that is very tight and well controlled as well. I haven't ever heard the stand mounted ones so I can't comment on those but if you have the space I'd say floorstanders in either Bob's design or the Pensil design.

Scott

mikje 13th January 2013 09:46 PM

UPDATE: I decided to go with Jim Griffin's MLTL design. At least for now. I've been listening to them quite a bit, but they're not yet broken in according to the manufacturer's recommendation. Even still, they are continually getting better. After a bit more break in time, I'm going to AB them with my current main speakers to see how they compare. Depending on that outcome, I might order another pair and go with either Dave's plans or Bob Brines's plans.
Thanks for all the input.
Mike


All times are GMT. The time now is 07:53 AM.


vBulletin Optimisation provided by vB Optimise (Pro) - vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2014 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.
Copyright 1999-2014 diyAudio


Content Relevant URLs by vBSEO 3.3.2