John Atkinson's Opinion on DIY - diyAudio
Go Back   Home > Forums > Member Areas > The Lounge

The Lounge A place to talk about almost anything but politics and religion.

Please consider donating to help us continue to serve you.

Ads on/off / Custom Title / More PMs / More album space / Advanced printing & mass image saving
Closed Thread
 
Thread Tools Search this Thread
Old 6th December 2012, 05:42 PM   #1
DavidL is offline DavidL  United States
Banned
 
Join Date: Jul 2010
Default John Atkinson's Opinion on DIY

Looks like all of us hobbyists and DIY builders can't call ourselves engineers

DeVore Fidelity Orangutan O/96 loudspeaker | Stereophile.com

Scroll down to "Admissions"
 
Old 6th December 2012, 06:30 PM   #2
diyAudio Member
 
Speedskater's Avatar
 
Join Date: Sep 2002
Location: Lakewood, Ohio
Where are the "Admissions" ?
__________________
Kevin
 
Old 6th December 2012, 07:00 PM   #3
DavidL is offline DavidL  United States
Banned
 
Join Date: Jul 2010
It's the title of what Mr Atkinson posted under
 
Old 6th December 2012, 07:01 PM   #4
DF96 is online now DF96  England
diyAudio Member
 
Join Date: May 2007
See the discussion forum at the bottom of the page. Its on the second page of the discussion (not the second page of the article). JA seems to say that unless you have sold something in the marketplace you cannot call yourself an engineer, and so perhaps should not criticise those who are (in his opinion) engineers.

He is confusing engineer vs. hobbyist with professional vs. amateur. An amateur is someone who does something because he loves doing it. A professional gets paid to do it, and may be required by his peers or statute law to adhere to some standard of ethics. An engineer is someone who applies science to solve real-life problems. A hobbyist is someone who does something in his spare time, so is almost synonymous with amateur.

Someone who sells lots of poorly designed speakers is a professional, not an engineer.
 
Old 6th December 2012, 07:25 PM   #5
Sfwg is offline Sfwg  United States
diyAudio Member
 
Join Date: Dec 2011
Quote:
Originally Posted by Speedskater View Post
Where are the "Admissions" ?
Ignore the main article and read the comments. "Admissions" is the title of one of the comments.
 
Old 6th December 2012, 10:55 PM   #6
Pallas is offline Pallas  Pakistan
diyAudio Member
 
Join Date: Aug 2004
Location: ATL
JA is, simply speaking, right. Though I haven't read most of the comments, from the 5-7 seconds I did spend reading them, JA's comment also was entirely out of the scope of the comments presented to anyone capable understanding written text. (A small minority of English readers, native or otherwise, sadly.)

Using out-of-scope diversions to "win" a debate is one of the classic techniques of propagandists and hacks, of course. Certainly, one must view JA as some combination of both propagandist and hack, even though he also provides a useful service to hobbyists by publishing real measurements of various speakers, including horizontal off-axis plots.

Still, as it stands JA's comment is strictly-speaking true. The gentlemen (presumably) in question can't claim the mantle of authority, in the way that someone with a track record of producing excellent speakers would. The merits of their arguments must speak entirely for themselves. (In this case, they do; the speaker's clearly a train wreck.)

Consider a disagreement about a minor point one that one is not interested enough to , if "Pallas" or someone else who engages audio on the hobbyist level exclusively was on one side, and David Smith (or someone else with a track-record of producing elite-level, superbly-engineered speakers) is on the other, one intuitively understands that burden of proof for each side is not the same: "Pallas" (or other hobbyist) has a much higher hurdle to clear than Mr. Smith would.

That's not to say all DIYers lack authority on loudspeaker design. In a "Battle of the Johns" (say, Krutke and Dr. Kreskovsky on one side, Atkinson on the other) any rational observer would give more weight to unsupported assertions by either John K than they would conflicting unsupported assertions by JA.
__________________
Serious Audio Blog

Last edited by Pallas; 6th December 2012 at 11:03 PM.
 
Old 6th December 2012, 11:30 PM   #7
diyAudio Member
 
Stormrider's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr 2006
Location: Connecticut
Blog Entries: 2
Send a message via AIM to Stormrider Send a message via MSN to Stormrider
You can't just take Atkinson's comment out of context. The guy JohnnyR made some valid points, but he was also attacking Atkinson personally. Anybody who reads stereophile knows most of it is written to appeal to non-technical readers. They throw in just enough actual data (most of it manufacturer supplied, with a couple measurements) to give the appearance they know what they're talking about, and to try and back up the airy descriptions of sound they give. This is nothing new.

If you don't like it, don't subscribe. If you feel the need to point out errors, or misconceptions in an article, do so, but do it politely. Atkinson is not an audio engineer. He's a writer, and therefore he is out of bounds with his comment referring to DIY groups, and should apologize... But he won't.

* I'm not referring to anyone in this thread, just commenting on what I gathered from the comments under that article.
__________________
AJ
 
Old 6th December 2012, 11:41 PM   #8
diyAudio Member
 
Kindhornman's Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug 2012
Location: Los Angeles, California
A point about Stereophile is that it is a commercial endeavor. It is not an engineering magazine. It is written by people who are not engineers. Though there have been some very detailed studies with Audio Precision test equipment used to show the actual measured response of loudspeakers if you read carefully you will see that often the reviews do not match the technical specification. They refuse to do double blind testing. And the most important fact is that no products are reviewed without a manufacturer advertising in the magazine. That fact alone should tell you something, these reviews are fairly much bought and paid for. Most speakers that are sold commercially use off the shelf components, nothing special and that is why so many sound so similar, they are just different boxes with the same exact speakers in the box. That is not engineering that is marketing and Industrial design.
 
Old 7th December 2012, 12:12 AM   #9
wayne is online now wayne  United States
diyAudio Member
 
Join Date: Jan 2002
Location: Northern California
Stereophile often reviews products with no ads every being run by the company! They have also given poor reviews to companies with large advertising budgets.
I don't know what JA's formal education background is but he has measured many speakers over the years, presented papers on these measurements and the correlations between them and the sound. He makes measurements with multiple types of test equipment not just AP and he is active at recording. I think he knows what he is doing after all these years. You can disagree with the reviews but don't need to attack the man or the magazine.
 
Old 7th December 2012, 12:24 AM   #10
DavidL is offline DavidL  United States
Banned
 
Join Date: Jul 2010
I find Mr Atkinson to be a rude and a not very knowledgeable person actually. Just because he knows how to push a few buttons doesn't make him an expert on speakers. He has in the past stuck his foot in his mouth often regarding audio but this time he's insulted the whole DIY community by saying what he did. Just putting out my feelings about the guy. He's not on my Christmas Card list.
 

Closed Thread


Hide this!Advertise here!
Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are Off
Pingbacks are Off
Refbacks are Off


Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
opinion of non diy dac nightanole Digital Line Level 3 14th May 2012 04:42 AM
F/S: John Risch DIY BASS TRAPS (4) rodge827 Swap Meet 1 27th September 2011 03:13 AM
looking for opinion xxxwhezzy Car Audio 9 8th May 2008 03:53 PM
Anyone who have been to the Northwest DIY, please give opinion on this speaker. zoooh Multi-Way 3 28th March 2003 02:27 PM
John H. Roberts DIY project in 1985 Audio Magazine coolohm Parts 0 28th June 2002 05:28 PM


New To Site? Need Help?

All times are GMT. The time now is 04:44 PM.


vBulletin Optimisation provided by vB Optimise (Pro) - vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2014 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.
Copyright 1999-2014 diyAudio

Content Relevant URLs by vBSEO 3.3.2