Leach Amp pcb group buy interest - Page 65

tryonziess · 14th November 2010, 10:36 AM

Brian,
Thanks for this bit of information. It must have taken a good bit of your time to compile this plot. I have substituted my rail voltage and Re values plus the 6 pair output and the current level is survivable. I doubt, while using music as the source, anything will begin to approach critical and still have your hearing intact.

In Dr. Leach's original Super Leach layout he pushed the rails to 93 volts and was able to maintain stablity and accuracy. Applying those methods to this layout should garner a degree of success.
I have been wanting any questions regarding the protection circuit to be cleared up before beginning a new group buy. It is hard to change once the copper is cut out of the pcb. Most of this is beyond my area of knowledge and trust to others for insight.

Tad

Luke · 15th November 2010, 05:24 AM

Hi Tad,

long time no talk. Did you complete you 12 trannie leach amp yet Im just wondering what protection you used and if you have stress tested it?
Im also curious to know how it sounds. I should begin mine soon, just finishishing off my current project and tossing up wether I build the Leach or buffalo32 next.

tryonziess · 15th November 2010, 11:07 AM

Luke,
I do not have an extremely sophisticatied setup for testing the amp projects. I have completely populated two of the Leach 12 clone boards and connected them to a crude power supply. The first attempt, with way too much bias, smoked the protection circuit. I removed the two resistors which supply feedback to the circuit and everything works O.K. I have quite a bit of 60 Hz. noise which I think is from the exposed crude wiring and such.

Since experimenting with this Bob Ellis and Brian have supplied some enlightening information concerning the protection apparatus. With my current setup 70 volt rails and .33 ohm emitter resistors I will try to calculate what substitutions I will need to get the most from this project.

I have backed off for now and think it is time to assemble the Dantimax remote FM tuner before doing anymore amp projects. I need to get some source hardware completed to my liking including a nice enclosure for the stepped attenuator unit.

I am also going to try and gauge interest in another Group Buy for this Leach 12 project in about another week or so. If we can get some more input on the protection circuit layout for all of the different voltage builds it would help those during assemble phase. I truly wish I had a setup to stress the Leach 12 to the max. I would like to see how much it can withstand.

Tad

BobEllis · 15th November 2010, 02:22 PM

Thanks, Brian.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Pingrs

In a belated response to Bob Ellis’s plea for a sanity check on his spreadsheets (and since to my knowledge no-one else has taken it on), here’s my two-pen’orth.

Load Line:

(As devised by David Eather and “Excelled” by Ben Janssen)

Cell B9 should read SQRT(2*B7/B5)..

Leach protection file

The lack of the volt drop across the emitter resistor in Bob’s spreadsheet renders the locus somewhat inaccurate. I’ve corrected that in my spreadsheet. Also, I’m not sure that a negative Vce can occur at the positive side of the output stage (or is this merely to allow higher Vcc’s to be displayed?). And the Vce plot should extend all the way to the 2Vcc limit*. I’ve also cleared up some (to me) confusion over designations. Note that only three points are needed to establish the complete protection boundary with such a simple scheme.

I’ve shown Protect_Locus_2 to emphasise the wisdom of including R13 in the protection scheme (the macro for this is not shown here). This enables the horizontal section in Locus_1 to slope below the 250ms SOAR, given suitable resistor values, something that cannot be done with the original Leach scheme. Now, nowhere does the protection locus violate this curve. The load lines may, of course, but that can be avoided by increasing the number of output pairs if the same power is to be achieved.

These schemes have serious limitations at this high(ish) supply voltage since using D1 referenced to 0V makes the break point Vce invariant at around 59V (for a 60V supply). Things get much, much worse when 70-80V rails are mooted. Here a variable break point or better still a triple locus is favoured, but that will require additional component locations on the pcb.

Nothing here is new, but a spreadsheet that instantly shows the effect of varying the supply voltage and resistor values superimposed on the SOAR and load line takes a lot of the headache out of choosing a protection locus.

If you see any errors let me know!

Brian.

*Ref. Michael Kiwanuka: Transparent V-I protection in Audio power Amplifiers (EW Sep-Oct 2002)

a.wayne · 15th November 2010, 02:31 PM

Tad,

What is the lowest PSU Voltage possible to operate the Leach 12 as currently configured ..

regards,

Quote:

Originally Posted by tryonziess

Luke,
I do not have an extremely sophisticatied setup for testing the amp projects. I have completely populated two of the Leach 12 clone boards and connected them to a crude power supply. The first attempt, with way too much bias, smoked the protection circuit. I removed the two resistors which supply feedback to the circuit and everything works O.K. I have quite a bit of 60 Hz. noise which I think is from the exposed crude wiring and such.

Since experimenting with this Bob Ellis and Brian have supplied some enlightening information concerning the protection apparatus. With my current setup 70 volt rails and .33 ohm emitter resistors I will try to calculate what substitutions I will need to get the most from this project.

I have backed off for now and think it is time to assemble the Dantimax remote FM tuner before doing anymore amp projects. I need to get some source hardware completed to my liking including a nice enclosure for the stepped attenuator unit.

I am also going to try and gauge interest in another Group Buy for this Leach 12 project in about another week or so. If we can get some more input on the protection circuit layout for all of the different voltage builds it would help those during assemble phase. I truly wish I had a setup to stress the Leach 12 to the max. I would like to see how much it can withstand.

Tad

BobEllis · 15th November 2010, 03:27 PM

Assuming that you have a string of 2x20V zeners in the front end, you should run at least 45-50V. Reduce the values of the zeners so that the cascode reference is lower and you can reduce the rails. I don't think I'd go much lower than 20V total for the zeners and 30V rails, but that is a number pulled from the air. When calculating the resistors feeding the zeners, change the "40" in the equation to the total of your zener string.

Luke · 16th November 2010, 03:52 AM

hi Tad,

I bought some surplus resistors and built 8ohm and 4ohm loads,I can pretty much test to 100 watts safely, I have no idea what these will resist, but given they are 1 inch diameter by 4 inches long I'm picking 100watts easy.

I like the idea of a spareset of boards, but its going to be awhile yet before I build these up. Im far too slow.

JCWagener · 16th November 2010, 12:00 PM

Hi people,

I searched but could not find anything. Are there any Leach designs that make use of SMT and double sided boards?

15th November 2010, 05:24 AM	#642
Luke diyAudio Member Join Date: Sep 2001 Location: Wellington NZ	Hi Tad, long time no talk. Did you complete you 12 trannie leach amp yet Im just wondering what protection you used and if you have stress tested it? Im also curious to know how it sounds. I should begin mine soon, just finishishing off my current project and tossing up wether I build the Leach or buffalo32 next. __________________ If you give a man a fish he will eat for a day. But if you teach a man to fish he will buy an ugly hat. And if you talk about fish to a starving man then you are a consultant. Dilbert

16th November 2010, 03:52 AM	#647
Luke diyAudio Member Join Date: Sep 2001 Location: Wellington NZ	hi Tad, I bought some surplus resistors and built 8ohm and 4ohm loads,I can pretty much test to 100 watts safely, I have no idea what these will resist, but given they are 1 inch diameter by 4 inches long I'm picking 100watts easy. I like the idea of a spareset of boards, but its going to be awhile yet before I build these up. Im far too slow. __________________ If you give a man a fish he will eat for a day. But if you teach a man to fish he will buy an ugly hat. And if you talk about fish to a starving man then you are a consultant. Dilbert

Thread Tools	Search this Thread
Show Printable Version Email this Page	Search this Thread: Advanced Search

Similar Threads
Thread	Thread Starter	Forum	Replies	Last Post
ezDAC Group Buy Interest?	ezkcdude	Group Buys	302	9th June 2011 01:33 AM
LME 49830 Group Buy Interest	tryonziess	Group Buys	1	28th August 2009 01:36 PM
Interest in a Tweeter Group Buy?	MattM	Group Buys	82	19th November 2007 04:43 AM

New To Site?	Need Help?
Register to Participate Search Privacy Statement Contact Us	Frequently Asked Questions Did you forget your password? Mark Forums Read


	Please consider donating to help us continue to serve you. Ads on/off / Custom Title / More PMs / More album space / Advanced printing & mass image saving

14th November 2010, 10:36 AM	#641
tryonziess diyAudio Member Join Date: Apr 2007	Brian, Thanks for this bit of information. It must have taken a good bit of your time to compile this plot. I have substituted my rail voltage and Re values plus the 6 pair output and the current level is survivable. I doubt, while using music as the source, anything will begin to approach critical and still have your hearing intact. In Dr. Leach's original Super Leach layout he pushed the rails to 93 volts and was able to maintain stablity and accuracy. Applying those methods to this layout should garner a degree of success. I have been wanting any questions regarding the protection circuit to be cleared up before beginning a new group buy. It is hard to change once the copper is cut out of the pcb. Most of this is beyond my area of knowledge and trust to others for insight. Tad

15th November 2010, 11:07 AM	#643
tryonziess diyAudio Member Join Date: Apr 2007	Luke, I do not have an extremely sophisticatied setup for testing the amp projects. I have completely populated two of the Leach 12 clone boards and connected them to a crude power supply. The first attempt, with way too much bias, smoked the protection circuit. I removed the two resistors which supply feedback to the circuit and everything works O.K. I have quite a bit of 60 Hz. noise which I think is from the exposed crude wiring and such. Since experimenting with this Bob Ellis and Brian have supplied some enlightening information concerning the protection apparatus. With my current setup 70 volt rails and .33 ohm emitter resistors I will try to calculate what substitutions I will need to get the most from this project. I have backed off for now and think it is time to assemble the Dantimax remote FM tuner before doing anymore amp projects. I need to get some source hardware completed to my liking including a nice enclosure for the stepped attenuator unit. I am also going to try and gauge interest in another Group Buy for this Leach 12 project in about another week or so. If we can get some more input on the protection circuit layout for all of the different voltage builds it would help those during assemble phase. I truly wish I had a setup to stress the Leach 12 to the max. I would like to see how much it can withstand. Tad

15th November 2010, 03:27 PM	#646
BobEllis diyAudio Member Join Date: Sep 2003 Location: Upstate NY	Assuming that you have a string of 2x20V zeners in the front end, you should run at least 45-50V. Reduce the values of the zeners so that the cascode reference is lower and you can reduce the rails. I don't think I'd go much lower than 20V total for the zeners and 30V rails, but that is a number pulled from the air. When calculating the resistors feeding the zeners, change the "40" in the equation to the total of your zener string.

16th November 2010, 12:00 PM	#648
JCWagener diyAudio Member Join Date: Nov 2010	Hi people, I searched but could not find anything. Are there any Leach designs that make use of SMT and double sided boards?