diyAudio

diyAudio (http://www.diyaudio.com/forums/)
-   Full Range (http://www.diyaudio.com/forums/full-range/)
-   -   TQWT Concrete cabinet attempt, building thread. (http://www.diyaudio.com/forums/full-range/145924-tqwt-concrete-cabinet-attempt-building-thread.html)

h@kan 15th June 2009 11:25 AM

TQWT Concrete cabinet attempt, building thread.
 
I have always wanted to build a pair of speakers in concrete but I have never find a way to do this in just one casting. The problem has been to get the form out from the finished cabinet. I talked about this with my colleague at work (im a civil engineer) and he suggested to build the form out of polystyrene and then either melting it with heat or chemically with thinner (Toluen) after the concrete has solidified. After testing the methods on a piece of polystyrene I decided to go for the chemical approach in my project.

Since I'm into transmission lines (at the moment) I decided to build a tapered quarter wave tube based on Martin J King Mathcad sheets, that I downloaded back in 2006 or so, but not yet have had the opportunity to try out. I'm sure the new updated (but unavailable to me) sheets are better but since this is more of an experiment in using concrete in the design than building the most optimized TL out there I'm happy that I still had the sheets on my harddrive.

The driver of choice is the Mark Audio CHR-70 that I have heard good things about.

After some hours altering the parameters in Mathcad I was quite satisfied with the teoretical result (as far as I knew with zero experience in designing TL's). So then I jumped on the building. The fun stuff in my opinion :)

First of all you need some special tools before the real work can start:

1. Someting to cut the polystyrene with: A simple "hot wire" saw.
2. Something to rotate the 60 kg heavy speaker with under the thinner melting process: A monstrous 3D-Rotator :)

Enough speaking, here are the result so far:

Hotwire saw

http://vps.stridfeldt.net/btg-tqwt/btg-tqwt_01.JPG

http://vps.stridfeldt.net/btg-tqwt/btg-tqwt_02.JPG

The tube cut out from polystyrene sheet

http://vps.stridfeldt.net/btg-tqwt/btg-tqwt_03.JPG

The edges are rounded a bit to give the concrete structure more strength

http://vps.stridfeldt.net/btg-tqwt/btg-tqwt_04.JPG

The raw tube form in the plywood form

http://vps.stridfeldt.net/btg-tqwt/btg-tqwt_05.JPG

Some details "shaped" in the polystyrene. Think of the polystyrene as a negative of what will become the cavity inside the concrete. The triangular shape will be a multi purpose cavity serving as terminal and holmholtz resonator or just as terminal depending on the results with the resonator.

http://vps.stridfeldt.net/btg-tqwt/btg-tqwt_06.JPG

http://vps.stridfeldt.net/btg-tqwt/btg-tqwt_07.JPG

http://vps.stridfeldt.net/btg-tqwt/btg-tqwt_08.JPG

The concrete is vibrated just enough to fill out the form.

http://vps.stridfeldt.net/btg-tqwt/btg-tqwt_09.JPG

http://vps.stridfeldt.net/btg-tqwt/btg-tqwt_10.JPG

http://vps.stridfeldt.net/btg-tqwt/btg-tqwt_11.JPG

http://vps.stridfeldt.net/btg-tqwt/btg-tqwt_12.JPG

http://vps.stridfeldt.net/btg-tqwt/btg-tqwt_13.JPG

http://vps.stridfeldt.net/btg-tqwt/btg-tqwt_14.JPG

h@kan 15th June 2009 11:27 AM

The speaker is mounted in the monstrous 3D-Rotator :)
I have no pics of the actual thinner melting process while it was quite messy and I did'nt wanna melt my camera aswell.

http://vps.stridfeldt.net/btg-tqwt/btg-tqwt_15.JPG

http://vps.stridfeldt.net/btg-tqwt/btg-tqwt_16.JPG

At this time all the polystyrene was gone, I tested to fill the tube with water to se if all polystyrene was gone and the water volume matched the theoretical volume.
The tube is around 25 liters and to melt the polystyrene I used about 2.5 liters of thinner. Don't try this indoors, the fumes was quite heavy even when working outside a windy day.
I rounded the edges and rubbed it with cement to get a raw concrete look.

http://vps.stridfeldt.net/btg-tqwt/btg-tqwt_17.JPG

http://vps.stridfeldt.net/btg-tqwt/btg-tqwt_18.JPG

http://vps.stridfeldt.net/btg-tqwt/btg-tqwt_19.JPG

http://vps.stridfeldt.net/btg-tqwt/btg-tqwt_20.JPG

http://vps.stridfeldt.net/btg-tqwt/btg-tqwt_21.JPG

http://vps.stridfeldt.net/btg-tqwt/btg-tqwt_22.JPG

http://vps.stridfeldt.net/btg-tqwt/btg-tqwt_23.JPG

http://vps.stridfeldt.net/btg-tqwt/btg-tqwt_24.JPG

http://vps.stridfeldt.net/btg-tqwt/btg-tqwt_25.JPG

http://vps.stridfeldt.net/btg-tqwt/btg-tqwt_26.JPG

This is where I am so far and I have started to play around with stuffing the pipe and different setups with the helmholtz resonator.
I have done some measurements but I dont know how relevant they are since my equipment is very "diy" (and my knowledge aswell), Panasonic WM-61A mic anf a cheap diy mic preamp.
I will post the graphs later anyway.

johngalt47 15th June 2009 12:11 PM

Fascinating!

I'm really interested in your hot wire saw. Did you make it yourself? What kind of wire is it? What voltage?

jackfish 15th June 2009 02:07 PM

For those who are attempting this in the future, straight delimonine will dissolve polystyrene. It is a little less volatile than other solvents.

delimonine MSDS http://www.supercoproducts.com/msds/MSDS-FLOAT.PDF

bjorno 15th June 2009 02:30 PM

Hi h@kan,

Nice project! Your hot wire saw set-up is genius, I will copy using the closeness of a window to avoid the smell of hot polystyrene.
Do you know that light weight ' EPS cement', http://www.epscement.com/ , have 85% less density than ordinary concrete mix, i.e. the weight could be reduced from 60 kg to about 9 kg without sacrificing good mold stability.

b

udailey 15th June 2009 02:46 PM

Way to DIY!!
Very nice idea and congratulations on your idea working! Will follow the thread for your listening impressions.
Uriah

qingcai 15th June 2009 02:48 PM

how is the sound?

planet10 15th June 2009 05:49 PM

Well done... not a whole lot of taper in the TQWT?

dave

yan6 15th June 2009 06:01 PM

I'm not sure on the scale, but I am wondering if the polystyrene could be replaced by plumbing, ie: 4 or 6" sewer pipe. This way you wouldnt have to melt it out and it would be smooth inside. Of course you are then limited to the shape of a circle?

Are these for outdoor use? What kind of driver will you use in them?

Great project! this sure sparked my interest if for outdoor use.

Keep us posted

mhconley 15th June 2009 10:22 PM

The creativity of people on this site never ceases to amaze. Excellent idea brilliantly executed. Looking forward to seeing more pictures and reading how it sounds.

Martin


All times are GMT. The time now is 04:11 PM.


vBulletin Optimisation provided by vB Optimise (Pro) - vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2014 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.
Copyright 1999-2014 diyAudio


Content Relevant URLs by vBSEO 3.3.2