So for you all i said is about the schematic.No i dont have schematic to show you.If you read all i wrote here you will see why.Thread here is not about what i made but about whats wrong in theory.....and is wrong.
Mikelandjelo said:
I hope you don't imagine that these two sentences say the same thing?Mikelandjelo said:
OK. Anyone who disagrees is deaf. Anyone who uses feedback is stupid.
Experience has taught me that in lots of professions (maybe all professions) it is possible to make a successful career while remaining blissfully unaware of even basic elements of the relevant knowledge base. In the case of audio engineering some understanding of feedback is part of the basic knowledge base.
I know EXACTLY what you are saying.
I thought this was my post for a moment; I agree with almost all of it
I too keep secrets and make no apology for that but I choose to point out, from time to time, when I see obviously bad thinking...there is a lot of it about...or I can help an amateur with something that isn’t obvious.
Last edited:
I said many times that i am not DIY-er.I said that i am making for living doing electrical engineering.And i never lied nither i lie at all.Traderbam figured clearly my point.Thank you for that.This thread is in "Everything else" and not DIY area.If someone doesnt seems to find him self usefull to be here i will not apologize for that.I pointed at something very serious that no one ever did.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Mikelandjelo
I achieved pure linear response without any negative feedback.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Mikelandjelo
So i built amp that i feel is good
Quote:
Originally Posted by DB69
I hope you don't imagine that these two sentences say the same thing?
Pure response means i measured it......feel means that i personaly feel its done right from music and feeling i have while i am listening it.not me,not few people but more than 100 heard it.Every single one noticed different emotion for same song on blind test.And this is the end about what i made.Point is wrong concept of whats in books.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Mikelandjelo
I achieved pure linear response without any negative feedback.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Mikelandjelo
So i built amp that i feel is good
Quote:
Originally Posted by DB69
I hope you don't imagine that these two sentences say the same thing?
Pure response means i measured it......feel means that i personaly feel its done right from music and feeling i have while i am listening it.not me,not few people but more than 100 heard it.Every single one noticed different emotion for same song on blind test.And this is the end about what i made.Point is wrong concept of whats in books.
Yes, we get your point. All the engineered systems and natural systems which use feedback are faulty. All the textbooks which encourage this are wrong. We (and Nature) should instead use your (unspecified) ideas.Mikelandjelo said:
Please tell us you don't work in military, healthcare or aerospace systems.
I am not working in military, healthcare or aerospace systems.I am little different from ordinary enginer and thats all.One more thing that i want to add about all what i said is that its possible to configure D class amplifier to work with different than ultra linear triangle oscilator and have linear-flat output response.Lot of what i said is very contradictory from what we all were doing (me not from 5 years a go when i decided to go deeper in this) but its true.I am not selling anything and have zero reasons to lie....I have discovered something new and i am pointing on it and discovering whats possible.I have full hands of work and i dont know will i be able to finalize in this year 2x2kw version that i started to work on today but i will try.....what i have done is 200W prototype that works amazingly well and just decided to scale it up.....once thats done probably i will make video of it and you will see what i am talking about.
I think it is time for the OP to put up or shut up. Claiming that you have discovered something which everyone else has missed is easy; backing up that claim with facts and figures and coherent argument is a bit harder - at this point it then usually become clear that the person has not gone beyond existing knowledge but is actually lagging far behind existing knowledge. The longer someone makes unsubstantiated claims the more likely it is that they will remain unsubstantiated on the grounds that they are false.
Please do not imagine that you can impress us with a video. We want facts: circuits, calculations, reasoned arguments, careful measurements.
Please do not imagine that you can impress us with a video. We want facts: circuits, calculations, reasoned arguments, careful measurements.
So i will do carefull measurements,will have reasoned arguments and will demonstrate all on video in real time.As engineer i think that i will have enough knowledge for that.....I am talking and if you have EARS to hear what i am talking that will be benefit for you....if you dont then you will see on video whats all about.Am i missing something DF96?
Anything you want my friend.....I will do all so anyone can file a patent for that and take all the credits.Why should i care about something that took me 5 years of life ?..... most important is to share.Philips,Sony and all other high end companies are doing that all the time.If you need something more just let me know.
Let me be clear,I dont care will video be enough or not....i dont care will you like it or not.Truth is that i made all what i said.I am spreading a word about it becouse i took all the benefit from same word from this forum.....and that word made me to push hard.I didnt know that i will make it untill i made it but i read a lot about all here on forum and of course on internet.So inspiration for hard work my friend is what you can benefit from my writing.
Once i said that sound is personal thing and thats what i really mean.....this is my personal built.I didnt make it to be rich and i dont give a f..k will someone like that or not.I made it for my self at first place.I will post video and thats MAYBE .... for me is enough great thing from God that i am the only person on Earth that can have this kind of design and enjoy in it every single day.All this should be enough for you all to push harder and achieve more than i did....if not i am really sorry.
Let me be clear,I dont care will video be enough or not....i dont care will you like it or not.Truth is that i made all what i said.I am spreading a word about it becouse i took all the benefit from same word from this forum.....and that word made me to push hard.I didnt know that i will make it untill i made it but i read a lot about all here on forum and of course on internet.So inspiration for hard work my friend is what you can benefit from my writing.
Once i said that sound is personal thing and thats what i really mean.....this is my personal built.I didnt make it to be rich and i dont give a f..k will someone like that or not.I made it for my self at first place.I will post video and thats MAYBE .... for me is enough great thing from God that i am the only person on Earth that can have this kind of design and enjoy in it every single day.All this should be enough for you all to push harder and achieve more than i did....if not i am really sorry.
As soon as it is disclosed, no-one (including you) can patent it anymore.
If it is not a commercial design, why don't you disclose the damn thing? All we know so far is that you claim to have made a good working class D amplifier using other techniques than negative feedback.
If it is a commercial design, why didn't you patent it before starting this ridiculous thread?
- Status
- This old topic is closed. If you want to reopen this topic, contact a moderator using the "Report Post" button.