New to world of DACs, etc...need resources to learn the basics

Status
This old topic is closed. If you want to reopen this topic, contact a moderator using the "Report Post" button.
Hi,
I am a virgin to DACs, well except for the built in ones in the various CDPs I have owned.

I recently purchased a nice Parasound CDP that has a digital out and would like to try using an external DAC...maybe even build my own. Problem os I know nothing about them and the various terms thrown around here...I.e. Clocks, IS2, toslink, spdif, etc...
I also have a nice Mac desktop that I understand can be turned into an awesome music server with the right gear connected.
I don't know where to start.....can anyone lead me to a good web article that explains all the basics so I can know where to start...I don't want to just start buying stuff and trying to make it work.

I did buy a DAC END2 kit a while back...I have populated all the boards and have everything to build it I think....I have put this on hold for now until I can learn a bit more about this stuff and hopefully what I have in this DAC END2.

Thanks a lot,
Signed,
Dacvirgin
 
I can't direct you to a particular website, but things you need to know about include:
sampling theory and Nyquist limit, Fourier theory, anti-alias filters, reconstruction filters, digitisation, quantisation distortion, clock jitter, I/V converters.

Bear in mind that some of the people who put information on web sites don't understand the basics of digital sound nearly as well as they think they do, so don't believe everything you read. In particular, there is a lot of nonsense around about NOS DACs - these have a place, but many of their fans don't understand them. If you see a website which shows 'ringing' on a pure square wave 'produced' by an OS DAC, then ignore whatever it says as the author clearly does not understand Fourier and anti-alias filters.
 
DACs are a fun aspect of DIY Audio, and important given that most recorded music is sold in digital form. There aren't that many all encompassing articles on DAC design that I know of, but here are some suggestions for you:

- Don't solely focus on the choice of which DAC integrated circuit you will use. The S/P DIF receiver, digital filter, output stage and power supplies are just as important.
- Don't fall into the 'they don't make them like they used to' trap. There's a lot of sites out there claiming that nothing made later than the TDA1541A and PCM63 is worth using. Those are very good ICs, but there are newer ones that are better.
- Read up on existing projects. The threads on this forum are probably the best source of information there is.
 
It may seem a bit odd to send you to TweakHeadz Lab Electronic Musician's Hangout, since it is a site about music recording, rather than playback, but although playback requires only a (stereo) DAC and recording requires both DACs and ADCs, which you'll find discussed under computer audio interfaces, there's a lot of relevant information there in one place, although you may want to skip over much of it. It's use-focussed too so there's a de-emphasis on the purely technical aspects, but it's by no means dumbed-down.

w
 
Can someone explain here the differences, pros, cons, applications of the different types of connections? I don't understand Toslink, SPDIF, IS2, etc....
My Parasound CDP has a digital out that looks just like an RCA Jack. The input of the DAC END2 has the same input.
I have a friend who has a Mac Mini he uses as a music server and he said what I need is a straight output like IS2 for this...I am confused about the different types of hook ups. What I would like to do is use my Mac as a music server and possibly use my Dac End2 as the DAC...I don't know what I need to do this....does the Mac have a digital out that I could somehow adapt to my Dac End 2 project?
Thanks,
Jeff
 
S/P DIF, or Sony / Philips Digital Interface Format is the single wire digital format used between transports and DACs. TOSLink is a way of carrying a S/P DIF format signal, it uses plastic fibre optics. S/P DIF is also commonly carried over coaxial cable terminated with RCA connectors. There is also a similar format used in professional applications that is carried by coaxial cable terminated with BNC connectors or shielded twisted pair cable terminated with XLR connectors.

I2S (pronounced I squared S, the 2 should be superscript), or inter-IC sound is an internal format used for short (>100mm) distances between ICs. This would be used between the S/P DIF receiver and digital filter, ore between the digital filter and DAC IC or similar applications. It is not intended to be used over significant distances, and isn't normally used to connect separate devices.

A Mac Mini will not have an I2S output. They have a mini TOSLink jack, shared for both digital and analog audio.
 
So, is the source of data from my Mac (regular Mac desktop) a good source? Do I need to put some sort of special sound card in the Mac to improve the source? The only outputs on the back of my Mac are USB....my DAC end then only has the SPDIF input.....can I easily add a Toslink input to the DAC End2? or, similarly, how can I get a digital signal mated from my Mac to my DAC End2 using it's existing SPDIF input?
Thanks, so far those info has been very helpful.
Jeff
 
What sort of digital input your DAC unit will have is a decision you'll have to make. If you want it to be compatible with the majority of digital sources, then S/P DIF is your only choice.

I2S can be made to work, but you'll have to get a source that outputs it (there are some, but not many). The connectors and signal levels are proprietary for external I2S, so a DAC designed for a transport outputting I2S will likely be compatible with just that one transport.

USB and Firewire are also options for between a computer and DAC, but you're not going to be able to DIY a Firewire DAC, and any DIY USB DAC isn't going to be that great.

So, is the source of data from my Mac (regular Mac desktop) a good source?

Probably not. What's a 'regular Mac desktop'?

... how can I get a digital signal mated from my Mac to my DAC End2 using it's existing SPDIF input?

Exactly what digital audio outputs does your computer have?
 
imho Fourier has nothing to do with no PCM neither DSD.

Digitizing basically is a decimation process of an analog signal to series of discrete values that means information in between samples lost forever. The opposite process that is taking place in DACs is interpolation. That is very important to note. Because everything else like digital filters square waves etc are buzz words of technicians that has to perfect real hardware designs but some of them do not understand the basics of the ADC-DAC the interpolation stage in particular.

Once again ADC-DAC is decimation-interpolation no matter what buzzwords are used multibit singlebit Nyquest etc. That is why some audiophiles prefer analog LPs to digital (RedBook SACD etc) in order to eliminate interpolation and use original signal instead. And some manufactures like Wadia are developing custom "restoring" algorithms (decent RedBook playback imho).

Probably this is a nice place to start with DIY DAC
The Buffalo II Digital-to-Analog Converter

imho SACD player is the way to go nowadays.
 
oh yeah because dsd (for sacd) is such an open format....

this limits you to using a sacd player and a VERY small number of diy hacked interfaces. it is very possible to have good usb sound via diy. the acko aku-24 is one quality interface and twisted paer along with exa devices and a couple of others are making good inroads. imo dsd is a limiting factor and there really is very little music that is available this way as opposed for hirez flac. if you are going this way, computer as source, dsd is not an option
 
Last edited:
Digitizing basically is a decimation process of an analog signal to series of discrete values...

True, although decimation should read sampling.

...that means information in between samples lost forever.

False. Samples are taken frequently enough that all components of the source which are audible can be (and are) reconstructed. This is a mathematical truth.

w
 
oh yeah because dsd (for sacd) is such an open format....
Unfortunately or fortunately because labels do care about quality recordings on SACD media since they are sure that would not be distributed via Internet worldwide tomorrow is not an open format. That is why computer DSD playback - SONY supports DSD playback on their VAIO notebooks for example - is not so practical since quality recordings above RedBook resolution is limited to SACD or DVDA media. DVDA are less popular among labels at ratio 2 to 1 in favor of SACD I would say but DVDA can be played on a regular PC tha is a bonus. I have Audigy 2 ZS so I tried - it works. Not sure if Meridian MLP decoded by Creative DVDA player or handled by sound card hardware. Most likely software playback. Anyway I prefer SACD or RedBook.

imho tweaking something like OPPO 93 with direct DSD playback would results in almost perfect playback device. Just an idea.
 
True, although decimation should read sampling.



False. Samples are taken frequently enough that all components of the source which are audible can be (and are) reconstructed. This is a mathematical truth.

w

Agreed with both statements 100%. I was trying to explain it in a way that emphasis the concept because sometimes professional vocabulary might made simple things harder to understand for a person who has no professional background in the area especially.

Also hardware that reveals all sonic potential of RedBookCD cost too much usually. SACD claimed to be more user friendly price-wise in advertisement articles at least.
 
[/QUOTE]


Probably not. What's a 'regular Mac desktop'?



Exactly what digital audio outputs does your computer have?[/QUOTE]

It's a one year old Mac desktop fully loaded with every option Mac offered one year ago. Other than that, I can't tell you much about it. It's my wife's rig.

It has two built in speakers and about six USB ports on the back....as far as I know that's it.
 
If you want to use your mac as a server, it will do just fine. The mini jack is a combination jack, so has both analog and an optical output. It works just fine, and at this point is the least of your concerns. You will need to connect a fiber optic cable to this jack with the appropriate connector, and the result you get is an optical SPDIF signal. You will need to either have a DAC with a toslink (optical) receiver, or standard coax. If coax, you will need to convert the optical to SPDIF. There are cheap and not so cheap converters available to do this.
 
Status
This old topic is closed. If you want to reopen this topic, contact a moderator using the "Report Post" button.