We all know that's just snake oil, right!
Exactly right. I've said it before and I'll keep saying it: KISS
Couldn't resist.
.
This is somewhat related: I´m looking forward to try a step-up output transformer in my tda1543 dac. I will try a garden variety low-VA trafo, I think the magnetisation losses/parasitics will be lower with a small transformer.
This was suggested by John (ecdesigns) in the ultimate tda1541 thread. His schematic showed the trafo in step-up mode, primaries in parallel, secondary driving a very high impedance, if I recall correctly.
Well, in my case I would drive a balanced interconnect directly from the trafo, and I´m not sure what I´d use on the receiving end. Suggestions?
This was suggested by John (ecdesigns) in the ultimate tda1541 thread. His schematic showed the trafo in step-up mode, primaries in parallel, secondary driving a very high impedance, if I recall correctly.
Well, in my case I would drive a balanced interconnect directly from the trafo, and I´m not sure what I´d use on the receiving end. Suggestions?
There is balanced (differential) routing cables and there is balanced (differential) signals...
Balanced signal - balanced wiring best
SE signal - balanced wiring very good if done correctly.
SE signal - SE wiring can be excellent (coax etc) or bad, but is the most prone to noise pick up so requires the most thought on shielding....
SE signal - balanced wiring is something i considered since my buffer and power amps have signal return connected to the boards not the chassis, well not directly anyway. I thought this might create a ground loop on each channel though.
Well, in my case I would drive a balanced interconnect directly from the trafo, and I´m not sure what I´d use on the receiving end. Suggestions?
Another transformer?
I have read that using cheap transformers can compromise SQ but done well they are very good at rejecting RF noise, it's not something i've seriously looked into though.
My reasoning is if one cheap trafo can compromise SQ, I´d rather not take my chances with two of them.
Then again, line input trafo always makes more sense (than output). We want to reject RF at the input of a component.
Any other suggestions? I have an idea, but I must look again at some jensen papers.
Then again, line input trafo always makes more sense (than output). We want to reject RF at the input of a component.
Any other suggestions? I have an idea, but I must look again at some jensen papers.
Last edited:
Studio guys often advise connect the shield at one end only, assuming balanced interconnections.
I must add I read this in the manual of a large format recording console. A transformerless design. A pretty bad recommendation, isn´t it?
Suggestion:
Test and measure in actual use. Decide which is "good enough". Report. I've been using mic cable SE for nearly 20 years, in lengths over 50 feet with no audible noise. That's good enough for my use.
Tested and measured, mainly by ear because my meter reads things but it can't hear anything.
Ready to report.
It's good enough! in fact i'm quite impressed
Thanks everyone for your balanced input
As for SE signal - that is (RCA) unbalanced analog interconnects, after reading and rereading Henry Ott, Bill Whitlock, Jim Brown and Bruno Putzeys several times, I would still go with a coax cable that has a heavy braided shield.There is balanced (differential) routing cables and there is balanced (differential) signals...
Balanced signal - balanced wiring best
SE signal - balanced wiring very good if done correctly.
SE signal - SE wiring can be excellent (coax etc) or bad, but is the most prone to noise pick up so requires the most thought on shielding....
Interesting read, explains the tradeoffs with grounding the screen on both sides vs send only, and also DC grounding vs AC grounding with a small cap, for RF only. (This is all for balanced interfaces and probably intended for long cable runs, but it´s interesting to try to understand these effects).
Design of High-Performance Balanced Audio Interfaces. Bill Whitlock. Jensen Transformers, Inc
http://sound.westhost.com/articles/balanced-interfaces.pdf
Design of High-Performance Balanced Audio Interfaces. Bill Whitlock. Jensen Transformers, Inc
http://sound.westhost.com/articles/balanced-interfaces.pdf
Last edited:
A simple low value cap where the cable enters the chassis to the chassis provides a low impedance path for RF signals...
The best place to learn all about this is...
Grounding and Shielding: Circuits and Interference: Ralph Morrison: 9780470097724: Amazon.com: Books
and possibly the definitive tome on the subject...
http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/04..._m=ATVPDKIKX0DER&pf_rd_r=08SGPSQ47CFM69BZK511
The best place to learn all about this is...
Grounding and Shielding: Circuits and Interference: Ralph Morrison: 9780470097724: Amazon.com: Books
and possibly the definitive tome on the subject...
http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/04..._m=ATVPDKIKX0DER&pf_rd_r=08SGPSQ47CFM69BZK511
- Status
- This old topic is closed. If you want to reopen this topic, contact a moderator using the "Report Post" button.
- Home
- Source & Line
- Analog Line Level
- Mic cable as single ended interconnects