best balanced volume control solution ?
Some of you can maybe help me to choose the best sounding solution to my balanced volume control problem?
I have a nice DAC board with balanced XLR outputs and I just bough a pair of professional studio monitors with balanced XLR inputs. That sounds good but I have no output volume control. I would like to add a volume control system at the output of my DAC board (see project.jpg)
- Target : choose the volume ctrl solution that will have the less impact on the sound quality (be the most transparent as possible)
- Constraints : since I live in a flat I usually listen to my music at low volume so I want to keep the best possible performance when volume is low
After searching on the web, here are some potential solutions :
Please help me to choose the best sounding one.
Solution 1: Passive resistance network (see solution1.jpg)
I found this recommended resistance networtk to control the volume using a simple potentiometer, but I am not very confident in its ability to drive correctly the amplifier input load at low levels.
Solution 2: passive resistance network + THAT 1606 balanced line driver (see solution2.jpg)
The THAT 1606 balanced line driver adds an additional stage in the signal path but it is a dedicated balanced driver that should drive correctly the amplifier input load even at low level.
Solution 3: back to unbalanced (see solution3.jpg)
Is it really a good a solution to go back unbalanced??? I am not confident in it.
Solution 4: digital volume control before DA conversion : doesn't look a good solution since I will not use the full dynamic range of the DAC.
Any other good sounding solutions are welcome :D
Does your DAC have enough output to drive the speakers to full volume? How about way more than full volume?
If you haven't tried the above, first re-record something at a minus 40 or 60 dB level so you don't blow them up.
Yes the DAC ouput can drive the monitor to full power.
From many months I search good sounding solution of digital potentiometer too. Now I work on optocouplers but I still afraid about influence into sound quality. I consider to implement the THAT2180 (voltage controlled amplifier) or TPL8002-25. Maybe the last IC would be sufficient? I do not know. I checked them. Does anybody use the TPL8002-25 as a digital audio potentiometer and what result obtained?
I like solution 1...KISS principle
log taper good quality pot
put it in a shielded box...metal can
Thank you for your answers,
I am asking myself if I can use solution 1 in front of a B1 buffer or a DCB1 buffer? :confused:
|All times are GMT. The time now is 12:28 PM.|
vBulletin Optimisation provided by vB Optimise (Pro) - vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2014 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.
Copyright ©1999-2014 diyAudio