Funniest snake oil theories

Status
Not open for further replies.
Its not hard to do a good crimp, not only planes but cars and other machines that are subject to high vibration (HIGH VIBRATION) use crimps with no problems, so forming one for DIY audio (or other systems) is not hard, instead of these silly negative posts all the time TRY IT.
Industrial Crimp Book - Molex:

Developed to replace the need to solder terminations, crimping technology provides a high quality connection
between a terminal and a wire at a relatively low applied cost. The methods for applying crimp terminations depend
on the application, volume, and range from hand-held devices to fully automated systems.

The application methods include a basic hand tool, a press and die set, a stripper crimper, or a fully automatic wire
processing system. However, no matter what method is used, the setup of each tool is critical for achieving a
quality crimp.

Today, many OEM companies are using Statistical Process Control (SPC) to continuously improve their crimp
terminations. Crimp termination is a complex process and to ensure consistent quality it is necessary to understand
the variability and inter-relational interactions that the technology involves.

Without a thorough understanding of the crimping process, and all the factors that can affect it, the result may not
meet expectations. The three key elements in the crimping process are the terminal, the wire, and the tooling.

Terminal:
For most applications, it is not economically practical for connector manufacturers to design a terminal to accept
one wire size, one wire stranding, and one insulation diameter (UL type) as well as Mil Specification. Most
terminals accommodate many wire sizes, stranding, and a range of insulation diameters, and the terminals are
designed to meet acceptable levels over this entire range.

Wire:
The wire stranding and insulation type can vary widely within one wire size. For example, there is more than 18%
more material in an 18 AWG by 19-strand wire than an 18 AWG by 16-strand wire. The insulation diameter of an
18 AWG wire can range from 1.78mm (.070") to over 4.57mm (.180"). Wire strands can be copper, tinned, over
coated, or top coated. Wire insulation materials, thickness, and durometers vary from application to application.

Tooling:
What type of tooling does the application require? Does the application require hand stripping of the wire or does
the volume dictate an automatic wire-stripping machine? Does the application and volume require hand tools,
press and die, or fully automatic wire process machines? Crimping with a manual hand tool, semi-automatic press
and die, or fully automatic wire processor, all involve different levels of variability. The terminal, wire, and type of
application tooling all affect the quality of the completed terminations.
 
Yawn, Frank Yawn, its creating a crimp, have you never done it for your car, do a pull test. Buy the correct crimp, the correct wire and a decent tool it doesn't cost the earth.
Instead of looking at/for solutions you just pull everything down with NO constructive content wot so ever. Glad you managed to google the molex crimp book it will tell you how to crimp...
You will harp on about crimps, but will happily solder, yet I wonder if you have had any training or done any tests, IPC-A-610 is a good start, all the assemblies and systems I work on are assembled by 610 qualified people, I often spend many a happy hour on SMT and assembly lines "playing".
 
Hi,



Nothing wrong with that.

http://ecx.images-amazon.com/images/I/81pxQMXUnNL._SL1500_.jp

Hasn't silk a slightly lower DA than cotton?
Might be hygroscopic though....

Cheers, ;)


Frank,

Your link doesn't work and your thinking on this issue doesn't hit home with me either.

Riboelectricity can produce electric potentials at line levels which are actually discernable by ear. I remember SY had an example some time ago.

At the same time, on DA, the field strengths in cable isolation is such, that I doubt the effect can be even measured at the lengths being used for audio. Anyways, coax with a PE insulation between core and shield is pretty affordable, and certainly is better in all respects than silk.

vac
 
Any scientific evidences for this, especially single stranded vs solid core, any thing I have worked on the choice fro stranded or solid was dependent on where the wire was installed and mechanical requirements, nothing to do with signal carrying ability. How can they be different and if so proof.
As for insulation effect - i though it's common knowledge that different insulations change basic parameters of the cable such as capacity/resistance/inductance. And these parameters often vary by as much as 10 times between the cables of different construction. And obviously frequency dependent...
As for stranded vs solid - only prsonal experience. While i can't say silver always beats good copper, i do can say that solid core (of equal quality and good construction) nearly always beats stranded in transparency, detail, and especially cleaner\detailed highs. I think the mechanism at work here is very similar to jitter in digital cables - it's measureable and is cable construction dependent.
Just a guess - in multi stranded copper the % of conductor which comes in contact with air and oxidise is much much higher than in solid core conductor. And the more inhomogeneity there is in conductor the more chaos it causes to a signal...there must be a reason we want 99.999% pure copper. Not as much for absolute conductivity of signal (which is already good at say 98%), but it's uniformity.
 
Last edited:
diyAudio Senior Member
Joined 2002
Hi,

At the same time, on DA, the field strengths in cable isolation is such, that I doubt the effect can be even measured at the lengths being used for audio. Anyways, coax with a PE insulation between core and shield is pretty affordable, and certainly is better in all respects than silk.

The purpose of the little "rope" is to prevent the loosely fitting sleeving from touching the conductor.
I don't see how that could generate a tribo electric field as there would be no rubbing involved (assuming rubbing a piece of rope over a metal conductor would do that)

As for the broken link, ignore it. It was a pic of the cover of Van der Graaf Generator's Still Life" album. Peter Hamill , remember?

As for crimping: that's fine if you can meet all the conditions for it to work. In case of the WBT connectors it was a solution looking for a problem.
Using several solid core wires crimped together + a little screw to hold it down was problematic to say the least.
They realized that and subsequently abandoned the idea.

Cheers, ;)
 
As for insulation effect - i though it's common knowledge that different insulations change basic parameters of the cable such as capacity/resistance/inductance. And these parameters often vary by as much as 10 times between the cables of different construction. And obviously frequency dependent...
QUOTE]

What a load of rubbish, how does the insulation effect resistance and inductance, a small effect on capacitance, but the rest.....
Do you know how a signal propagates...electrons for a start drift at 0.1mm/sec approx. not very fast....
 
Last edited:
As for stranded vs solid - only prsonal experience. While i can't say silver always beats good copper, i do can say that solid core (of equal quality and good construction) nearly always beats stranded in transparency, detail, and especially cleaner\detailed highs. I think the mechanism at work here is very similar to jitter in digital cables - it's measureable and is cable construction dependent.
.

LOL
 
What a load of rubbish, how does the insulation effect resistance and inductance, a small effect on capacitance, but the rest.....
Do you know how a signal propagates...electrons for a start drift at 0.1mm/sec approx. not very fast....
Insulation affects cable construction which results in it's final characteristics.
Van den Hul Magnum Hybrid:
capacitance - 21 pF/m
inductance - 0,83uH
impedance - 199oHm
Kimber Kable 8TC
capacitance - 313 pF/m
inductance - 0,13uH
impedance - 20oHm
Tara Labs RSC PRIME 500
capacitance - 21 pF/m
inductance - 0,79uH
impedance - 85oHm
XLO ULTRA 12
capacitance - 167 pF/m
inductance - 0,24uH
impedance - 38oHm

And please do not make pointless posts. Either provide arguments or don't post.
 
Last edited:
Nope different THICKNESSES of insulation will affect inductance (2mm PVA and 2mm Teflon will have the same inductance), insulation has NO effect on resistance, and the Er and size of insulation will affect capacitance. If we are going to make statements that are facts lets be a bit more accurate.
I did not make a pointless post, I put LOL, explain the mechanism of how multi stranded is worse than single core, I would also be interested on what you think causes digital jitter in cables and how you equate this to an audio analogue signal.
As I asked do you understand how signals propagate down wires, along PCB traces...
 
Nope different THICKNESSES of insulation will affect inductance (2mm PVA and 2mm Teflon will have the same inductance), insulation has NO effect on resistance, and the Er and size of insulation will affect capacitance. If we are going to make statements that are facts lets be a bit more accurate.
I did not make a pointless post, I put LOL, explain the mechanism of how multi stranded is worse than single core, I would also be interested on what you think causes digital jitter in cables and how you equate this to an audio analogue signal.
As I asked do you understand how signals propagate down wires, along PCB traces...

Of course, difference insulation has an effect of resistance..... resistance of the insulation it self. :rofl:
 
How is this so, though, what mechanism is at work here there has to be some reason and measurable data behind this... though its not something I have some across in other areas of electronics (discounting high frequency/power where litz is used). Skin effect is not an issue at audio frequencies so we can discount that.
 
Yawn, Frank Yawn, its creating a crimp, have you never done it for your car, do a pull test. Buy the correct crimp, the correct wire and a decent tool it doesn't cost the earth.
Instead of looking at/for solutions you just pull everything down with NO constructive content wot so ever. Glad you managed to google the molex crimp book it will tell you how to crimp...
You will harp on about crimps, but will happily solder, yet I wonder if you have had any training or done any tests, IPC-A-610 is a good start, all the assemblies and systems I work on are assembled by 610 qualified people, I often spend many a happy hour on SMT and assembly lines "playing".
The point of the quote is the emphasis within on it having to be done right, for the joint to have proper integrity - I can't recall at the moment where I came across the other discussion, but it focused on the drastic loss of quality in the crimped joint when some aspect of the process was not 100% correct - I think for an aircraft I would require a bit more than a pull test, :).

My constructive comment is that it is the subtle flaws in the assembly that can cause sound quality problems - you know, that boring ol' concept of a chain and its links ...
 
Hi,



Not if you use high purity silver (99.9999% is about as good as it gets) IME.
Of course you could also use gold plated silver.



There's always that but it has to remain manageable, right?

Cheers, ;)

The purer the silver the faster it tarnishes. In fact some of the other metals in silver alloys are specifically chosen to reduce silvers tendency to tarnish.

The slowest tarnishing silver I've come across were contact pins for multicore connectors at work. They were made of a silver nickel alloy with at least 10% nickel.


The 6mm^2 were an extreme example. 2.5mm^2 copper still has a lot less resistance per m than 1.5mm^2 silver.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.